/srv/irclogs.ubuntu.com/2007/02/07/#ubuntu-kernel.txt

=== peernaute520 [i=PeerTV-C@sta21-3-82-244-157-42.fbx.proxad.net] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== peernaute520 [i=PeerTV-C@sta21-3-82-244-157-42.fbx.proxad.net] has left #ubuntu-kernel []
=== zul [n=chuck@ubuntu/member/zul] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rikai [n=rikai@unaffiliated/rikai] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rikai [n=rikai@unaffiliated/rikai] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== _MMA_ [n=mma@cpe-071-070-203-016.nc.res.rr.com] has left #ubuntu-kernel []
=== _MMA_ [n=mma@cpe-071-070-203-016.nc.res.rr.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== zul [n=chuck@CPE0006258ec6c1-CM000a73655d0e.cpe.net.cable.rogers.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
kylemcrimsun, ping03:02
BenCkylem: Hey03:30
BenCkylem: You busted acx :)03:31
kylemeh?03:31
BenCwait, I misread the diff03:31
BenCI thought it lost the firmware_ver stuff03:32
kylemi'm pretty sure it's ok03:32
kylemi test bilt it03:32
BenCbut loading it would have been the problem03:32
BenCthe firmware_ver stuff was all custom code I added a while back to make it easier to change to a different firmware03:33
kylemheh, i read through the diff too03:33
kylemhmm, this alsa-firmware thing is confusing.03:33
BenCwas the firmware_ver merged upstream?03:33
BenCkylem: FYI, debian/commit-templates/external-driver for new drivers03:34
kylemno clue, i just read through the patch.03:34
kylemBenC, eh? that's what i did.03:34
kylemgit commit -a -e -F debian/..03:35
BenCdamn, am I losing it or what03:35
kylemget some sleep, hehe03:35
BenCremind me not to review commits on 4 hours of sleep03:35
zuli hear beer helps03:35
kylemas long as it isn't a bad bear.03:36
zuli was thinking kieths03:36
kylemnm. inside joke.03:36
zulmeh..03:36
kylemBenC, i thought the only removed firmware stuff was some legacy crap03:36
BenCkylem: in acx? Yeah, some ancient shit03:37
kylemhehe03:39
zulremind me never to read the forums please03:41
BenCI've managed to stay away from the forums03:49
zulsomeone was spreading disinformation..03:49
BenCmisinformation on a public internet forum? Say it ain't so :)03:55
zuli know!03:55
BenCNext you'll be telling me Slashdot doesn't have trolls03:56
zulhehe03:56
ajmitchbut the ubuntu forums are different! they're *official*!03:59
kylemofficially full of muppets.03:59
zulnight folks..04:08
=== kylem can't figure out where some of this alsa firmware is hiding.
kylemsome of it is actually GPL and provides src.04:36
kylemBenC, sounds good to me.04:54
BenC$ file ubuntu/net/atl1/atl1_main.c 05:06
BenCubuntu/net/atl1/atl1_main.c: HTML document text05:06
=== BenC looks at kyle
BenCkylem: You sure you test compiled the HTML in the atl1 driver directory? :)05:07
kylemuh. oops.05:07
BenC4 of them05:07
kylemyeah, i clearly wget'd the wrong thing. shit.05:07
kylemBenC, probably forgot to turn the option on.05:08
kylemsigh. fucking kernel.org gitweb breaking my workflow.05:08
kylemso, why did 3 of them work... weird05:10
BenCheh05:10
kylemchrist. fucking kernel.org is so fucked.05:11
BenCI'm uploading a new lrm tonight, but I'm delaying the kernel upload till after our bug day tomorrow, plus so I can merge some VMI patches05:12
=== zul [n=chuck@CPE0006258ec6c1-CM000a73655d0e.cpe.net.cable.rogers.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
kylemfixed.05:13
kylemwill push in a second.05:13
lifelessis the past tense wgot ?05:54
kylemwifuckedup05:55
crimsunkylem: pong05:59
kylemcrimsun, what's the deal with these alsa-firmware bits?06:00
kylemi notice some of them are actually GPL and stuff, but i can't figure out where they're hiding06:01
crimsunkylem: the ones in the upstream tarball of the same name or the source package on REVU [revu.tauware.de] ?06:01
kylemthe former.06:01
kylemah, i see.06:02
kylemi didn't think to look in revu, thanks.06:03
=== rikai [n=rikai@unaffiliated/rikai] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rikai_ [n=rikai@unaffiliated/rikai] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== Lure [n=lure@external-7.hermes.si] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== zul [n=chuck@CPE0006258ec6c1-CM000a73655d0e.cpe.net.cable.rogers.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rikai [n=rikai@unaffiliated/rikai] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== Lure [n=lure@external-7.hermes.si] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== Sky_walkie [n=root@193.85.244.121] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== Sky_walkie [n=root@193.85.244.121] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== Sky_walkie [n=root@193.85.244.121] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== Sky_walkie [n=root@193.85.244.121] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rikai_ [n=rikai@unaffiliated/rikai] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== sky_walkie [n=hrdlo@193.85.244.121] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== marcin_ant [n=marcin@aim181.internetdsl.tpnet.pl] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rikai [n=rikai@unaffiliated/rikai] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== Keybuk [n=scott@quest.netsplit.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rikai__ [n=rikai@pool-72-65-111-33.ptldme.east.verizon.net] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== snail [n=syeates@syeates.oucs.ox.ac.uk] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== thom [n=thom@amnesiac.heapspace.net] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== jwest-- [n=unidenf@unaffiliated/jwest/x-422957] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== pmjdebruijn [n=pmjdebru@pmjdebruijn.xs4all.nl] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== pkl_ [n=phillip@lougher.demon.co.uk] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rikai [n=rikai@unaffiliated/rikai] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
TheMusoc01:23
=== sky_walkie [n=hrdlo@193.85.244.121] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== fabbione [n=fabbione@modemcable178.77-70-69.static.videotron.ca] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== Keybuk [n=scott@quest.netsplit.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rpereira [n=rpereira@ubuntu/member/rpereira] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
zulguys, im just going through the linux-meta bugs and assigning them to the right component02:46
=== CyberSnooP [n=chatzill@cp284147-b.dbsch1.nb.home.nl] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
CyberSnooPI'm getting a kernel Oops when booting herd 3 desktop cd. Anyone who can help me making a useful report out of it?02:47
zulCyberSnooP: if you have a digital camera, open a bug report in launchpad and attach it to the bug report.02:49
CyberSnooPwell. It continues booting after the oops.02:49
CyberSnooPI'm trying to get the dmesg output transferred to somewhere I can make a bug report from02:50
zuldmesg > dmesg.txt and copy the dmesg.txt somewhere02:52
CyberSnooPdone so. Are there any hints on searching for previous reported bugs?02:53
CyberSnooPwell. there seem to be only 3 bugs (!!) in feisty. Searching by hand isn't that hard, or I just don't understand launchpad yet02:55
=== gnomefreak [n=gnomefre@ubuntu/member/gnomefreak] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
pkl_BenC: ping03:00
CyberSnooPah.. well, if anyone cares: found the relevant bug (#76294), but that tells me to use a newer linux-restricted-modules, which I guess is pretty hard on a CD :(03:04
pkl_the atheros bug?03:05
CyberSnooPyep03:07
CyberSnooPCould it be affecting the installation also? (since the installer also hangs on hardware detection)03:07
pkl_kernel oopses often do random nasty things to the kernel, and so it could affect the installation yes.03:08
CyberSnooPAre new 'nightly' desktop CDs up to date? Is it worth burning one of them an trying installation again?03:09
BenCpkl_: yo03:12
=== ..[topic/#ubuntu-kernel:BenC] : BUG DAY!! | Ubuntu kernel development discussion ONLY | Kernel Wiki: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/KernelTeam | 2.6.20-6.11 - Things are getting solid now. Use it, but there are still a few missing modules.
pkl_BenC: hi, ready for the bug tutorial?03:13
BenCyeah03:13
BenCkylem: done coding HTML to help with bugs? :)03:13
kylemheh03:14
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: don't use /feisty/+bugs or similar03:15
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: that doesn't mean what you think it means :) kernel bugs in feisty are on /ubuntu/+source/linux-source-2.6.20/+bugs03:16
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: hang on hardware detection> try booting with hw-detect/start_pcmcia=false; that was in the Herd 3 release notes03:16
CyberSnooPcjwatson: sorry for the wrong bug report lookup, but I finally found the right set of bugs an found a exisiting bug report (atheros oops)03:17
BenChttps://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux-source-2.6.20/+bugs03:17
BenCCyberSnooP: atheros oops should be fixed in latest lrm03:17
CyberSnooPcjwatson: will try with special boot options, thanks for that hint :)03:17
kylemcan we blacklist modules from the kernel cmdline?03:17
BenCNot in Herd3 though03:17
BenCkylem: I wish03:17
kylemshouldnt be hard to add...03:18
CyberSnooPBenC: Yep, but I'm trying herd 3, so that doesn't really help right now :)03:18
BenCCyberSnooP: Daily iso's03:18
BenC185 bugs in 2.6.2003:18
BenCis there no sorting!?03:19
BenC"kernel oops while installing win 2k sp2"03:20
BenCheh, that looks funny03:20
zulBenC: which one is that?03:23
pkl_first things, how do you get a listing of all bugs in 2.6.20?03:23
BenChttps://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux-source-2.6.20/+bugs03:26
=== heno [n=henrik@ubuntu/member/heno] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
BenCWe need to start with bugs who's Status is !Unconfirmed03:27
BenCcheck if we have any patches we can apply immediately03:27
BenC36885 is something we can fix with a dmi match entry03:28
BenCkylem, pkl_: either of you know how to add dmi match for nolapic forcing, or should I do it real quick?03:30
CyberSnooPBenC: can't find hw-detect/start_pcmcia=false in Release Notes (http://www.ubuntu.com/testing/herd3) but I wlil try it anyway. Is there anything usefull to report about the hw-detect hang (althought this probably isn't -kernel talk anymore)03:30
kylemBenC, i can do that.03:30
kylemi'll try to not write it in htm.03:30
kyleml03:30
CyberSnooP(note: I'm installer hang right now)03:30
BenCkylem: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux-source-2.6.20/+bug/36885 assigned to you then03:31
BenCkylem: hehe03:31
pkl_36885 is confirmed...03:31
fabbioneBenC: or add a debian/rules to strip html at build time :)03:31
kylemi've been doing some thinking, we need to sit down with colin and mdz at some point and think about how we're going to handle dapper.03:31
fabbioneeven better.. patch gcc :)03:32
BenCkylem: Good topic for next summit03:32
BenChttps://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux-source-2.6.20/+bug/6430803:32
kylemi have a few patches that really should make it into stable, but it's kind of scary to think about, so i'd rather have two kernels, one which might actually propogate to -updates.03:32
BenClooks like another dmi match entry03:32
BenCkylem: We can't propagate to updates03:32
kylemBenC, ? why not?03:33
zulBenC: im just cleaning up linux-meta as well03:33
BenCnot because I don't want to, but because it's a real ugly issue with -security and -updates syncing03:33
kylemah.03:33
kylemlazy archive admins, gotcha. 8)03:33
BenCI was warned by adam that doing it would be the same as the ghost busters cross streams03:33
kylemBenC, mind going through bug targetting in a bit?03:33
BenCsure03:33
kylemBenC, hey, don't forget, they crossed the streams to defeat zul...03:34
BenClol...so Chuck will die if we upload kernels to -updates03:34
=== kylem signs some packages.
=== BenC ponders that one for a moment
kylem;-P03:34
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: the release announcement had it (https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-devel-announce/2007-February/000243.html)03:34
kylemi do ever so much hate xen...03:34
zulmeh..03:34
zulkylem: whats wrong now?03:35
kylemzul, nothing.03:35
kylemzul, just teasing.03:35
=== zul develops a complex
BenCpkl_: want to try your hand at a dmi match for disabling acpi-video on a particular bit of hw?03:35
mjg59BenC: What was the reason for that?03:36
CyberSnooPcjwatson: okay, but that says "5 minutes" and the alternate cd. I'm having a >5 minutes hang on the desktop one03:36
cjwatsonah, probably not much you can do to avoid it short of grotty expert hacking03:36
pkl_BenC: I can try, but dmi match means nothing to me...03:36
kylempkl_, it's basically like a pci id, but for the acpi bios, i guess.03:36
kylempkl_, works more or less like a pci quirk03:37
mjg59kylem: Eh. Not quite - it's not anything to do with acpi03:37
CyberSnooPcjwatson: It says it's loading 'aec62xx' and since I can't find a bugreport for that I was wondering if there is anything to report03:37
kylemmjg59, ah, i just associate dmi with acpi, what's the diff?03:37
mjg59pkl_: DMI is a spec for putting system information in the BIOS, including vendor and product strings03:37
kylemoh. DMI is for SMBIOS?03:37
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: you sure that's the desktop CD? I wouldn't expect that level of information to be visible on the desktop CD03:37
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: what does the screen look like? blue with a white box in the middle?03:37
CyberSnooPcjwatson: nope :) It's ubiquity with the GTK progess bar and a line below03:38
mjg59pkl_: When all else fails, you can break drivers so they don't do something on machines with a given DMI ID03:38
CyberSnooPHowever, I picked the dutch translation03:38
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: oh, I see, OK. same boot option is worth a try then03:38
BenCpkl_: Basically you create a table of stuff to match a specific machine type based on it's dmidecode output03:38
mjg59In some cases, it's appropriate - in others, it's arguably better to figure out why the machine is breaking03:38
CyberSnooPokay, will do. Nothing to catch while it's hanging now?03:38
BenCpkl_: drivers/acpi/sleep/main.c: Look for acpisleep_dmi_table03:40
pkl_is this dmi match stuff already done in Ubuntu, and so there's a framework to look at to start from?03:40
pkl_ah, ok.03:40
BenCpkl_: Use that same logic to make the drivers/acpi/video.c driver not work for the machine in https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux-source-2.6.20/+bug/6430803:40
BenCThere's an attachment with dmidecode output03:40
pkl_ok.03:40
mjg59BenC: Uh, in future we're going to be moving to depending on more functionality provided by that driver03:41
mjg59I'd prefer to spend a bit more time trying to debug it03:42
henoAm I right in guessing that bug 80892 is a kernel bug or is that a brltty bug? the log says 'kernel: [  138.396000]  usb 3-1: USB disconnect, address 3' right after brltty tries to mount a USB device03:43
mjg59BenC: Also, I can't actually see ACPI code being executed on modprobe, which leaves me a little concerned about why this is happening03:44
mjg59Oh, I see03:45
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: well, you could look at 'ps ax' from a terminal to see what it's doing03:49
BenCmjg59: Do you think it's fixable? I'm happy just disabling for feisty...it's a long standing bug03:49
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: could be unrelated to the pcmcia thing03:49
BenCfor that machine I mean03:49
CyberSnooPcjwatson: sorry, you just missed it by 1 minute.. rebooting with new kernel option now. Will find out if pcmcia was the problem in about 30 minutes I guess :)03:50
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: *nod*03:50
mjg59BenC: No idea. I've asked for more information.03:50
mjg59BenC: The bugs marked as duplicates are entirely unrelated03:50
mjg59I've de-duped them.03:50
BenCmjg59: It sounds an aweful lot like a BIOS bug to me, but if you think it might be fixable, then have at it03:51
BenCpkl_: dequeue that bug for now :)03:51
pkl_hmm, ok, in the middle of reading the code.03:52
kylemif there's only one thing this job is good for, it's touching parts of the kernel you would never, ever, otherwise touch.03:52
BenCpkl_: Feel free to study the dmi match stuff...it's useful for workarounds like this03:52
kylemlike, why the fuck would i ever want to look at mmc... but yesterday...03:52
pkl_yeah03:53
BenCkylem: Yeah, like I gave up HTML coding a decade ago, but then yesterday... :)03:53
kylemBenC, ferfuckssake.03:53
kylem;-)03:53
=== BenC wont let that one go for awhile
mjg59BenC: Oh, it's quite possible that it's a BIOS bug03:55
mjg59But that doesn't mean it's unfixable03:55
BenChttps://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux-source-2.6.20/+bug/6781003:57
BenCbug 6781003:57
BenCcan we get ubugtu in here?03:57
BenCwho maintains that bot?03:57
zulseveas i think03:57
BenBugtu67810: bad hard disk noise on shutdown03:58
BenCthere, now I get warm fuzzies03:58
BenCAnyone have any comments on that bug? Seems like upstream is ignoring it03:59
mjg59I suspect just checking through the libata shutdown code would give a good idea about what's going on03:59
BenCand the comments on it have digressed a lot03:59
mjg59Yeah, we're not going to get anything useful out of the bug04:00
kylemhehe.04:00
kylemdo we have the acpi ata driver in .20, hmm....04:00
BenC"Does OpenSuse have a net-install..."04:00
kylemBenC, oh yeah, i got that bug and was like "plonk"04:01
BenCmjg59: Is there a working libata-acpi.c for 2.6.20?04:01
kylemthe blind, lead by the deaf, lead by the dumb.04:01
BenCis that from libata-dev git?04:01
kylemBenC, alan posted it the other day.04:01
BenCkylem: "I see, said the blind man to the deaf man"04:01
kylemmight be a useful fallback.04:01
kylemICUP04:02
BenCI'm waiting for the bug report that says "If I tap three times on the left side of my box, it works...can you code this workaround into the next kernel"04:02
bubbasucksBenC: can i bug you real quick? just wondering what your ID search came up with04:03
BenC"FIxed...included kick-box.ko, just use the tap=left-side, count=3 modparams"04:03
BenCbubbasucks: I found nothing useful04:03
bubbasucksso the pci ids were in megaraid_mm ?04:03
BenCIn megaraid_mbox04:03
bubbasucksok04:05
mjg59BenC: Yeah04:05
bubbasucksi'll try just including megaraid_mbox in initramfs04:05
bubbasucksand take megaraid out04:05
mjg59kylem: Nah, that's pata_acpi04:05
kylemah.04:05
mjg59kylem: Which is different - it's actually a full pata driver04:05
mjg59It just uses acpi to get resource information04:05
=== mdz [n=mdz@cpe-76-173-8-128.socal.res.rr.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
mjg59So it's better than pata_generic04:06
zulBenC: if you click your heels three times does it work?04:06
BenCmjg59: Does it supercede libata-acpi?04:06
mjg59No04:06
mjg59Entirely different04:06
mjg59libata-acpi provides acpi glue for libata04:06
BenCDo we need libata-acpi in feisty?04:06
mjg59pata_acpi is a driver04:06
mjg59Yes04:06
BenCwhere's it at?04:10
mjg59lkml right now04:10
mjg59It's not terribly important04:11
mjg59Or libata-acpi? There's a branch of libata with it04:11
BenCOk04:12
BenCMoving on to 74059: ata2 timeouts, fails to boot04:13
pkl_BTW as a total aside, how long do people spend reading lkml?  I've not had time to look at it once this week.04:13
zuli try to do it everyday04:14
zul...but thats just me04:14
CyberSnooPcjwatson: I guess it's not pcmcia, the kernel boot option didn't help and ubiquity is hanging on "Module 'aec62xx' for 'IDE chipset support' is being loaded...'04:14
BenCpkl_: I scan subjects...rarely do I read content unless it's interesting04:14
pkl_yes, I like skimming it.  Pity kernel-traffic disappeared, that was a good way to catch up.04:15
CyberSnooPpkl_: lwn is somewhat a replacement for kernel updates04:16
=== bernard_ [n=bernard@mersenne.largestprime.net] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
pkl_is the openSuse comments of any relevance?  I notice 'More' didn't respond regarding the driver loaded04:17
pkl_CyberSnooP: lwn is a sort of replacement, but is mainly complemented kernel-traffic.  Lwn concentrates on one or more selected kernel topics per week in depth, kernel-traffic just summarised all the traffic that week...04:19
BenCOk, pulled in libata-dev:acpi04:19
CyberSnooPpkl_: that's true. Just stay subscribed to kt-distrib@... maybe they'll be back sometime :) 04:20
zulBenC: #79331 our 2.6.20 supports rt73 now does it?04:20
BenCzul: I'm a little skeptical...we actually should have always supported it, but now I've switched back to legacy04:21
CyberSnooPsomeone here in the mood for determining why hw-detect stops on aec26xx? (I've got a hanging installation from herd 3 right now)04:21
zulBenC: so ill reject it04:22
BenCCyberSnooP: I can't even find that driver04:22
CyberSnooPoh, sorry.. aec62xx04:22
CyberSnooPat least, that's what is reported as the module name04:23
BenCThat module I can find :)04:23
BenCCyberSnooP: Are you able to switch to the log console when it freezes, tried SysRq?04:24
CyberSnooPit doesn't freeze and desktop is still usuable04:24
BenCCyberSnooP: Maybe before it gets to that point you can delete that module from /lib/modules/...04:24
CyberSnooPthere is just no progress04:24
cjwatsonhang on, is it just the installer that hangs? or the entire system?04:24
CyberSnooPso: just installer is dead. I do see 4 "modprobe" processes on "ps ax" output in terminal window04:25
cjwatsonmodprobing what?04:25
BenCso modprobe is hanging04:25
BenCcjwatson: We need to donate some hardware to kernel.org or something04:26
BenCgitweb is so useless04:26
CyberSnooPhmm, i see even more modprobing going on. Lot's of modprobe -Q pci:.... and a modprobe -v aec62xx04:26
BenCCyberSnooP: Can you list all the modules that you see being modprobed in ps?04:26
BenCMaybe we could rsync all the git trees and provide a mirror04:27
CyberSnooPBenC, will try.. pity there is no irc-client on the live cd, copy & pasting would have been nice now04:27
cjwatsonthere's gaim, though it's not great04:27
BenCCyberSnooP: telnet :P04:27
cjwatsonor you can just install one on the fly04:27
CyberSnooPhttp://bram.vleur.nl/tijdelijk/ps-ax.txt04:30
CyberSnooPscp does work :)04:30
cjwatsonthat D-state modprobe doesn't look happy04:30
=== Lure [n=lure@external-7.hermes.si] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
CyberSnooPah. D = Uninterruptible sleep  (usually IO). (didn't know that)04:32
BenCkylem, pkl_: On to 75626: spurious 8259 interrupt disabled IRQ04:32
=== kylem sighs. it would be really nice if bugs.launchpad.net/# DTRT
cjwatsonkylem: launchpad.net/bugs/#04:33
kylemcjwatson, yeah, but i'm used to typing bugs. (for bts.)04:34
CyberSnooPcjwatson: any other info that might be of any use?04:35
pkl_isn't problems like that due to wrong DSDT tables?04:36
jwest-anyone using vmware here? vmware by default installs scsci drives right?04:37
BenCCyberSnooP: dmesg if you can04:38
jwest-had an issue and i just booted scsi.s kernel  and bam it worked04:38
CyberSnooPhttp://bram.vleur.nl/tijdelijk/dmesg.txt04:39
CyberSnooPwhich looks like a dmess to me 04:40
BenCCyberSnooP: wow, that's an ugly mess04:40
BenCCyberSnooP: Do you have some whacked partition map or something on there?04:40
=== ivoks [n=ivoks@34-158.dsl.iskon.hr] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
CyberSnooPnope.. hda1 hda2 both ntfs, hda5 ext3 for root, hda 6 for swap04:41
CyberSnooPfdisk -l /dev/hda output: http://bram.vleur.nl/tijdelijk/fdisk-l.txt04:42
BenCThe system keeps saying it's trying to read beyond the end of the device04:42
CyberSnooPwell, I do see the "does not end on cylinder boundary" warning for the first time (although they may have been here for quite some time)04:43
mjg59BenC: We still have no HPA support for libata, BTW04:44
mjg59That's pretty critical04:44
BenCCyberSnooP: your partition map doesn't match what the kernel sees04:44
BenCmjg59: Can you point me to where that is?04:44
CyberSnooPwell, I didn't repartition with the installer. I'm reinstalling from an (old) edgy installation on the same harddisk04:45
mjg59BenC: Unimplemented04:45
CyberSnooP(i didn't repartition at all in the mean time)04:45
BenCCyberSnooP: weird...so this is a regression?04:45
mjg59BenC: See idedisk_check_hpa in drivers/ide/ide-disk.c04:46
CyberSnooPI would guess so. At least dapper installed cleanly on the same laptop, although I'm not really sure if it was exactly the same partitioning04:46
BenCmjg59: Isn't this why you were suggesting we didn't switch to pata yet? :)04:46
mjg59BenC: Probably04:46
BenCI didn't actually switch that many04:47
mjg59CyberSnooP: Oh, uh. You might actually be hitting this precise issue.04:47
CyberSnooP(i did dist-upgrade from dapper to edgy, but since feisty wasn't booting I decided to go for the re-install.. there you have the woll story)04:47
BenCmjg59: He can't be, he's still using an ide driver04:47
mjg59Oh, right04:47
mjg59Yeah, fair enough04:47
BenCCyberSnooP: Where does feisty stop booting?04:48
CyberSnooPafter dist-upgrade04:48
CyberSnooPIt's a different problem I guess, since it didn't boot X04:48
CyberSnooPI messed a lot with drivers, mesa and stuff during edgy04:49
BenCso it booted, just didn't start X?04:49
BenCcjwatson: Is there a way to drop to shell before livecd gets to starting up too much?04:50
CyberSnooPyeah, sorry about the confusion. It did boot. although I'm not sure which kernel I last used04:50
CyberSnooP(might have been 2.6.19)04:50
BenCpkl_: Want to investigate #76489?04:53
BenCMaybe there's some update to the r8169 driver...I'm leaning toward thinking it's an locking issue triggered because we have SMP by default04:53
pkl_just let me have a loot at it...04:53
cjwatsonBenC: break=top? (or premount, or casper-bottom, or ...)04:54
BenCmaybe there's an updated driver somewhere04:54
BenCCyberSnooP: Can you try booting with cjwatson's suggested cmdline and delete the aec62xx driver, then let the boot continue?04:54
BenCsee if that gets you through this, then we can investigate the problem afterwards04:54
CyberSnooPsuggested: break=top ?04:55
BenCyeah, try that one04:55
BenCloading aec62xx on my box doesn't produce a hang or errors04:55
=== tuxmaniac [n=aanjhan@unaffiliated/tuxmaniac] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
CyberSnooPwell, break=top throuws me in a busybox with "(initramfs)" prompt04:57
maks_how surprising :)04:58
CyberSnooPbut I'm not quite sure where the aec26xx module should be right now04:58
CyberSnooPnot in /lib/modules/2.6.20-6-generic 04:58
pkl_BenC: I'll have a look at it.  What was the resolution re: bug no. 75626 (spurious 8259....)?04:59
CyberSnooPoh  sorry, it is there05:00
bubbasucksBenC: is the megaraid_mbox.c file online or available because i looked in 2.6.17 megaraid_mbox.c here (http://www.gelato.unsw.edu.au/lxr/source/drivers/scsi/megaraid/megaraid_mbox.c) and didnt see 101e 1960 1028 051105:00
CyberSnooPI found /lib/modules/2.6.20-6-generic/kernel/drivers/ide/pci/aec62xx.ko Just remove that file and it shouldn't complain further on?05:00
mjg59What's loading that file?05:01
mjg59BenC: I'll open a bug on the HPA issue05:01
BenCCyberSnooP: that's what I'm hoping :)05:03
BenCbubbasucks: gitweb on kernel.org, ubuntu-2.6 tree05:04
BenCif you can get it to answer05:04
CyberSnooPWe'll find out.. (in 30 minutes :( )05:04
cjwatsonBenC: driver-backports ping?05:07
BenCcjwatson: working on it while I'm doing bugs :)05:08
CyberSnooPside-note: the new partitioner has gone crazy on me now05:10
BenCThere's something whacked about your partition map05:10
CyberSnooPyeah, but this is an UI error i think05:10
BenCAh, ok, blame cjwatson then :)05:10
CyberSnooPboth the OK and Cancel buttons in the  "Edit partition" dialog stopped responding05:11
CyberSnooPI'm getting to fast at using it after 6 install attempts05:11
BenCGive it a second, sometimes there's lag after clicking it05:11
CyberSnooPI gave it 90 seconds now05:11
CyberSnooPkilled all ubiquity, starting over now.. I'll try to be nice to the buttons05:13
bubbasucksBenC: k05:13
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: ubiquity --debug and file a bug with /var/log/installer/debug, /var/log/syslog, and /var/log/partman attached please; use a password you don't care about in debug mode05:17
CyberSnooPcjwatson: will do some other time I guess. It seems like some kind of race when I quickly hit the format checkbox and open the edit dialog05:17
=== FabioNET [i=500@217.201.37.216] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
CyberSnooPcjwatson: besides this error the new partitioner is very nice though! Pretty usuable, quick, and to the point. 05:18
cjwatsonaha, I can fix that05:22
cjwatsoninsufficient locking05:22
cjwatsonCyberSnooP: off-topic for this channel, but thanks, fixed for the next release05:25
CyberSnooPcjwatson: hah... that's what I call "getting things done" :) While we're in this words-of-praise moment: mjg59: nice blog-article on suspend/resume with acpi 05:26
\shguys, what about HP P800 SmartArray SAS/SATA controller and 64bit LBA support in our kernel? I just need some practical experience with it, if it's working or not...a nice to have is a statement "yes, it works, even with a MSA 60 attached to it" or "yes/no, support is a bit flaky" or "no, smartarray driver doesn't support 64bit lba, means partitions greater 2TB" ;-)05:30
BenC\sh: How about "I don't know?" :)05:31
kylemmjg59, wow. we don't have HPA support yet? fucking hell.05:32
pkl_what is _HPA_ support?05:32
\shBenC: then I say "hmmm..who could know" or "who has such a hardware, and runs it" or "ok, I'll google" ;)05:33
mjg59Host Protected Area05:33
mjg59Drives can flag a portion of themselves as unusable05:33
kylem"utter retarded"05:33
mjg59And then optionally password that05:33
mjg59Unless you explicitly request that they disable that, the disk just appears smaller to the OS05:33
mjg59Usually used for hiding recovery areas at the end of the disk05:33
pkl_or port :-)05:34
mjg59The problem is that at some point in 2.2, somebody added HPA support to Linux05:34
pkl_port -> porn... joke05:34
mjg59And decided that the sensible default would be to disable it05:34
mjg59So people install Linux into the HPA-covered area without ever noticing05:34
mjg59We can now never change that default05:34
mjg59Except libata doesn't support disabling the HPA05:34
=== cassidy [n=cassidy@host-213-189-171-21.brutele.be] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
mjg59Hilarity ensues05:35
kylemfsvo hilarity...05:35
pkl_okay, that's how manufacturers get away with supplying machines without Windows reinstall disks....05:35
kylemright.05:35
mjg59Yeah, it's basically impossible to fuck with it in Windows or DOS05:35
pkl_But as Ubuntu does have HPA support, it will happily over-write it on the first instal.05:36
kylemhmm. kernel could catch the access past the end of device, disable HPA, and restart the xaction...05:36
kylempkl_, it's only a problem going from edgy->feisty with pata, iirc.05:37
kylemsince libata for sata disks wouldn't ever have supported it.05:37
mjg59Right05:37
mjg59Though it would actually be interesting to test05:37
mjg59The alternative is that the lack of HPA support somehow magically results in the entire disk being available05:37
kylembut drivers/ide did, so when you boot a pata-*.ko system with it, you die horribly.05:37
mjg59Though I'm pretty sure that's not the case05:38
CyberSnooPaec62xx is still being loaded in hw-detect :'(05:38
kylemmjg59, how much work is it to disable? restarting the bio shouldn't be too too hard, i would think.05:38
mjg59kylem: Eh, almost none. 05:39
CyberSnooPokay, I'm being evil now in the hope to progress somewhat. I've killed the "log-output -t hw-detect modprobe -v aec62xx" process, this however results in alim15x3 being modprobed and ALSO hanging05:40
CyberSnooPso this seems to be a more general IDE-driver thing than specifically the aec62xx05:41
CyberSnooP(hanging means: process state = D for the modprobe process)05:41
pkl_did you check the modprobe -v aec62xx process did die?  It if was in an un-interruptible sleep, then killing it is impossible.05:43
CyberSnooPpkl_: it didn't die. But the installer doesn't seem to care about that process05:43
pkl_yeah, but the other modules being modprobed might...05:44
CyberSnooPit goes on for every ide driver now. I've got 7 state=D modprobes right now05:45
bubbasucksBenC: its not in there05:47
bubbasuckshttp://bugs.donarmstrong.com/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=39517405:47
bubbasucksthere is a patch to add CERC ATA100 raid i believe05:47
bubbasucksbut it's not listed in your megaraid_mbox.c05:47
cjwatsonBenC,mjg59: what happened to the iSight firmware loader bits from mjg59's patch? The rest of it (uvcvideo driver update) seems to have been applied05:54
BenCI just took the 0004-isight patch as-is...don't know about anything on top of it05:54
BenCbubbasucks: Ok, applied that patch, so it will be in the next kernel upload05:55
cjwatsonthe Apple Remote patch seems to be still missing05:55
cjwatsonmjg59: any idea of the iSight status? the firmware extractor was really a separate binary so I guess it shouldn't be in the kernel anyway05:56
cjwatsonah, Apple Remote went into ubuntu/mactel/05:59
bubbasucksBenC: so i'll need to downgrade my firmware to 6.6106:00
bubbasuckshope that doesn't blow away my raid config06:00
mjg59cjwatson: Uh. Which firmware loader bits?06:01
mjg59I moved the firmware-loading in kernel06:01
cjwatsonmjg59: so you did; I must have an earlier version of the patch06:02
mjg59Ah, ok06:02
mjg59It still needs the extractor, yeah06:03
mjg59I *really should* have an Apple next week06:03
mjg59It's taking an age to get through Intel06:03
BenCAnyone know if there's a project for rtl818x and rtl8187 that is newer than 1.5 years?06:06
kylemBenC, there isn't, afaik.06:06
kylemBenC, i think it's a dead-end chipset (no new hw)06:07
BenCnot dead to our users :/06:07
=== Eruantalon [n=hans@5634185c.rev.stofanet.dk] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
bubbasucksBenC: it appears that CERC raid w/ FW>6.61 is broken in megaraid_mbox, but rolling back to 6.61 breaks disks >128GB06:07
BenCI'd ask for a user to donate one of them so I can fix the crash, but then we probably wouldn't have any more users with the card :)06:08
=== holycow [n=a@mail.wjsgroup.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
BenCbubbasucks: Do you have a disk > 128GB in there?06:08
bubbasucksyep06:08
BenCThe patch doesn't say that > 6.61 is broken, just that if you have problems, try downgrading fw06:08
bubbasuckshttp://groups.google.com/group/linux.debian.bugs.dist/browse_thread/thread/54a1ca21b839ebf1/4a0cd669217f3c7d?lnk=st&rnum=1#4a0cd669217f3c7d06:08
bubbasuckshttp://linuxwarez.us/url/RwU4l906:09
bubbasucks^ short version06:09
BenCStill seems like fw > 6.61 isn't a sure fire problem, just that it might be06:09
BenChopefully it isn't for you :)06:10
bubbasucksi'll give it a try06:11
bubbasuckswhen will the next kernel be out?06:12
=== pinskian [n=plen@unaffiliated/pina] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
bubbasucksBoth Dell and LSI Logic have indicated that they no longer support these 06:18
bubbasucksmodels in the 2.6 kernel. As a result, these adapters are not supported 06:18
bubbasucksin Red Hat Enterprise Linux 4.06:18
bubbasuckslame06:18
=== bleinmono [n=toffel@ppp85-141-149-36.pppoe.mtu-net.ru] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
bubbasuckstime to go back to software raid...06:18
BenCkylem: Can you check the work queue fixes in rtl_ieee80211 to see if they may be the cause of the regression in rtl818x (bug 78255)?06:22
kylemsure.06:23
CyberSnooPJust to let you know: Killing the "log-output modprobe"-processes was sufficient to make it to the end of the installer. Rebooting the installed feisty was hell (>300s) but after an update to today (with new restricted modules) it works perfectly06:24
BenCCyberSnooP: Great, thanks06:26
pkl_Regarding bug #75626 (Spurious 8259...) there's a bug on the kernel.org bugzilla with a huge number of similar problems with many more HP Pavilion laptops (bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=7562).06:32
kylembrb. lunch.06:33
=== Lure [n=lure@clj46-234.dial-up.arnes.si] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
BenCpkl_: You should be able to link the bug report on launchpad to that kernel.org bugzilla report06:37
BenCpkl_: Click on Also affects: "Upstream..."06:37
=== rpereira [n=rpereira@ubuntu/member/rpereira] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
pkl_ok.06:37
BenCand point it towards "linux" as the target and add the URL you gave06:37
BenCkylem, pkl_: Updated ipw3945 to v1.2.0...might consider it for dapper and edgy06:38
BenCrequires new microcode as well06:41
=== johanbr [n=j@JBrannlund.MathStat.Dal.Ca] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== sky_walkie [i=sky_walk@r27s01p03.home.nbox.cz] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
mjg59BenC: Any chance you can turn on CONFIG_PM_TRACE?06:51
mjg59Contrary to what the docs say, the default is no longer to screw up the clock06:51
mjg59And it's very handy for tracking down suspend/resume problems06:52
BenCSure06:56
mjg59Sweet06:58
mjg59Thanks06:58
BenCI don't see that option06:58
=== doko_ [n=doko@dslb-088-074-026-072.pools.arcor-ip.net] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
mjg59Might need PM_DEBUG enabled06:58
mjg59Ah, yes06:58
BenCah, right06:58
=== heno [n=henrik@ubuntu/member/heno] has left #ubuntu-kernel ["Leaving"]
BenCmjg59: Want this enabled too?07:13
BenC    Keep console(s) enabled during suspend/resume (DANGEROUS) (DISABLE_CONSOLE_SUSPEND) [N/y/?]  (NEW) 07:13
mjg59BenC: Leave that at N, I think07:26
=== pwnguin [n=jld5445@camaro.cis.ksu.edu] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
pwnguinif today's bug day, ive got a pet bug in launchpad; it's got a patch attached and everything, just needs someone to look at it07:28
=== ivoks [n=ivoks@34-158.dsl.iskon.hr] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
pwnguinbug #7702607:29
mjg59BenC: Uh, yeah. Weren't you supposed to be re-applying that?07:29
BenCThought I had that one in there07:37
pwnguinwell, you "fixed" it07:37
pwnguinbut it didnt work07:38
BenCpwnguin: done07:39
pwnguinhuzzah07:40
pwnguini'll definately test it when it gets pushed out and report back :)07:40
BenCIt's pushed to git, but if you're waiting for it to be uploaded, it will probably be available tomorrow some time07:47
pwnguinhmm07:47
pwnguinim supposed to be doing some kernel development for my master's project07:47
pwnguinalthough i doubt ill have git mastered in before it hits the repo07:47
BenChttps://wiki.ubuntu.com/KernelGitGuide :)07:51
pwnguinnoted, though i have a ton of bioinformatics lab to do today =/07:51
BenCWhy are people still filing bugs on 2.6.19 :/07:53
pwnguinas in they don't know better, or as in it affects .19 only?07:54
zulBenC: muppets07:56
=== ajmitch was still running .19 unti last night :)
pwnguinajmitch: but did you file bugs against it?07:59
ajmitchnah, I just couldn't be bothered rebooting07:59
pwnguinheh07:59
pwnguinmy video card fan is too loud for that08:00
BenCpwnguin: As in .19 isn't even in ubuntu anymore08:01
zulheh...08:01
zulnot for main at least08:01
pwnguinBenC: well, i meant like, they filed against .19 when they were running .2008:03
pwnguinfor "dont know better"08:03
BenCno, they just haven't upgraded in 2 months :)08:03
pwnguinwell, those are easy ones to close08:04
pwnguin"we think its fixed in .20. upgrade and retest"08:04
pwnguinkthnxbye08:04
BenCkylem: ping 3395008:08
=== cberl1 [n=berloc@mars.dsbn.edu.on.ca] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
cberl1Is there any reason a kernel panic wouldn't leave some kind of log on the system when it appears?  Something strange going on with one of my servers.08:10
BenCcberl1: Yeah, because it crashes so hard that disk write is either impossible, or dangerous08:10
pwnguincberl1: hope you have a serial cable / port08:11
cberl1Okay, and possible solutions?08:11
BenCcberl1: That sort of crash needs a screen to see and you can take a digital photo for a bug report08:11
cberl1Ah, now there's the problem:  recreating the issue while having access to the console.  Can I reroute the console to an SSH session?08:12
BenCNo, else the system would be alive enough to use a shell too :)08:12
BenCif you can redirect console to a serial (via the BIOS for example), then that would probably be best08:13
BenCleave a screen'd minicom on it with capture enabled08:13
BenCI do that frequently for my ultrasparc08:13
cberl1Okay, minicom on another machine, I assume?08:13
pkl_the machine with the other end of the serial cable...08:14
cberl1Okay.  I'll have to dig up such a beast.  Don't have any other PCs available for that at the moment.  Might be able to reclaim one of the "thin clients" temporarily.08:15
cberl1xconsole wouldn't work, would it?08:15
johanbrI also think there are patches to do the serial console thing over USB or Ethernet instead. Does the Ubuntu kernel contain any of those patches?08:16
cberl1xconsole looks like it might do the job for now - just keeping it open on my screen now, watching what's going on.  Quite a bit of traffic when you're the hub for 30 clients, eh?  :)08:20
=== cberl1 [n=berloc@mars.dsbn.edu.on.ca] has left #ubuntu-kernel []
kylemBenC, sorry, my irc was gone completely haywire.08:54
BenCkylem: I was going to insert an HTML coding joke here, but I think you've had enough :)08:55
kylemheh.08:55
kylemBenC, hmm. i think i posted a patch for that a while back, will update. need to repost the smapi stuff eventuall...08:55
=== CyberSnooP [n=bvleur@cp284147-b.dbsch1.nb.home.nl] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== sky_walkie [i=sky_walk@r27s01p03.home.nbox.cz] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== sky_walkie [i=sky_walk@r27s01p03.home.nbox.cz] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== FabioNET [i=500@217.201.3.109] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== rpereira [n=rpereira@ubuntu/member/rpereira] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== sdrik [n=sdrik@ip-93-4.dsl.newel.net] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== pinskian [n=xfs@unaffiliated/pina] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== sdrik [n=sdrik@ip-93-4.dsl.newel.net] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== CyberSnooP [n=bvleur@cp284147-b.dbsch1.nb.home.nl] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== holycow [n=a@mail.wjsgroup.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== zul [n=chuck@CPE0006258ec6c1-CM000a73655d0e.cpe.net.cable.rogers.com] has joined #ubuntu-kernel
=== pwnguin [n=jld5445@camaro.cis.ksu.edu] has left #ubuntu-kernel []

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.7 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!