/srv/irclogs.ubuntu.com/2008/01/16/#ubuntu-x.txt

ubotuNew bug: #183416 in xorg (main) "screen is enlarged very much when I enable my graphics card(NVDIA card)" [Undecided,Incomplete] https://launchpad.net/bugs/18341604:05
ubotuNew bug: #40659 in dmidecode (main) "[ia64] Can't get past "Configuring xserver-xorg"" [Medium,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/4065905:46
Q-FUNKre06:45
brycehey06:55
Q-FUNKno wonder batman's patch would not apply:  it needs to apply after everyone else's patch is there :)07:00
bryceheh07:08
Q-FUNKI'm building myself a test package07:16
Q-FUNKI'll try it with both -amd and the -siliconmotion on my laptop07:17
bryceamazing how much time this friggin equipment takes to make it work07:18
brycecan't believe I've put an entire week into ume, and I feel barely further along than a week ago07:18
Q-FUNKindeed07:20
Q-FUNKit almost feels like rocket science07:20
tjaaltonbryce: apparently there is a libdrm release coming up in the next few weeks07:38
tjaaltonbryce: which means that the TTM API is finished..07:39
tjaaltonRAOF has snapshot packages for libdrm, so I'll try to build the intel stuff against it07:40
brycetjaalton: amazing!07:41
brycekewl07:41
tjaaltonthe diff against 2.3.0 is over 6MB :)07:42
tjaaltonbut that includes the kernel drivers too, same for bsd07:42
brycetjaalton: I made some good progress on ume today.  Preliminary results show that the lockup is solved.  I'm hoping by the time i get up tomorrow we'll be close to done with it07:42
tjaaltonbryce: that was with poulsbo?07:43
bryceyeah I bet.  The libdrm2 patch I was manhandling for ume was like 16,000 lines07:43
bryceyup07:43
tjaaltonhehe07:43
tjaaltonso I tried RAOF's nouveau packages yesterday, and it worked quite well07:44
brycenice07:44
bryce3d stuff?07:44
tjaaltonobviously no 3D, and no VT07:44
tjaalton:)07:44
bryceoh07:44
tjaaltonit's flaky07:44
tjaaltonbut the software rendering wasn't too bad07:44
bryceok, so worked quite well for certain definitions of quite well ;-) ;-)07:44
tjaaltonyeah07:45
tjaaltonthe VT's not working is a known issue07:45
tjaaltonno DRI since there was no driver for it07:45
tjaaltonbut according to the wiki it's known to be broken for most07:46
tjaaltonjcristau: RAOF also promised to co-maintain nouveau on git.d.o :)07:46
tjaaltonthe package is derived from -nv, so it's close to the XSF standards07:47
bryceI hate it when VT switching is broken.  makes debugging a pain07:47
tjaaltonyep07:47
bryceah really...  is it a superset of -nv yet?07:47
tjaaltonno, obfuscated parts are mostly rewritten, so it's a fork but has more functionality now07:48
tjaaltonso I'm not proposing to replace -nv with it, not for hardy anyway :)07:49
brycewell, still good to heaer about the progress07:49
tjaaltonalthough it seems that there are serious issues with -nv where on some models you need the binary driver to "prime" the card"07:49
tjaaltonand nvidia is not going to fix that07:50
brycewow07:50
bryceI didn't know about that07:50
brycewow that sucks07:51
tjaaltonI'm not sure how common that is07:51
brycemaybe it's updating bios or something?07:51
tjaaltonpossibly07:51
tjaaltoni'll dig up the bug on b.fd.o07:52
tjaaltonhmh, can't find it08:04
bryceah well08:04
brycemight be good to note on our wiki somewhere08:05
tjaaltonbut there was one where aaronp said that "there's nothing we can do about it right now" or similar08:05
bryceoh btw, the bug I mentioned in that tagging greasemonkey script is fixed now08:05
tjaaltonoh, cool08:06
brycebrian also added some tooltips to it (haven't checked that out yet)08:06
tjaaltonso are the ume guys switching to hardy now?08:09
tjaaltonand would that be an excuse for putting the new drm stuff in the kernel?-)08:09
brycethey're shooting for hardy yes, but gutsy is a backup in case we can't get things like X to work on it08:10
bryceunfortunately time is very short to prove it on hardy, which is why everyone's scrambling08:10
tjaaltonyep08:11
tjaaltonwe'd get TTM with the drm, although that was declined at UDS08:11
bryceit looks like they've accepted that they're going to be running non-stock ubuntu, with loads of PPA bobbins stuck ontop, so they're working to the assumption that they'll be carrying drm bits and pieces08:11
bryceI'm sure they would love hearing new drm included in main ubuntu, but don't think they're expecting it08:12
bryceit would be >awesome< to have TTM08:12
tjaaltonI'm not exactly sure what would break with it, since it's not like a requirement to use it08:13
bryceyeah08:13
tjaaltonbut intel surely is going for it08:13
brycemvo would be happy08:13
tjaaltonhehe08:13
tjaaltonso, I'll break my laptop now08:14
brycewell, if nothing else, it'd be nice to stick it in a ppa for people 08:14
tjaaltonyeah08:15
bryceI'm sure dell would snag it for their systems08:15
bryce(assuming it doesn't eat kittens and make babies cry or something)08:16
mvobryce: looks like I missed the earlier bits of the conversation :) ? new intel drivers?08:17
tjaaltonmvo: libdrm release due "in a few weeks"08:18
brycemvo, with TTM08:18
tjaaltonwhich would include the new memory manager (TTM)08:18
mvooh, with ttm ?08:18
mvonice08:18
tjaaltonso I'll try to package the intel branch that uses it08:18
tjaaltoncurrently the performance with 965 is actually worse than with the old driver, but that's hopefully fixed soon08:19
* mvo nods08:19
mvowill this branch do redirected direct rendering? 08:19
tjaaltonI mean with TTM, worse than the current driver with EXA (amazed that it's actually possible..)08:20
tjaaltonmvo: I think that's a separate issue08:20
tjaaltonalthough it would require TTM yes08:20
mvook08:22
mvothanks08:23
brycetjaalton: I got another meeting with Intel about -intel bugs tomorrow, but I've been so busy with ume stuff I haven't put much thought into what to talk about.  Are there any issues you think would be worth bringing up with them?08:38
bryceoh speaking of which, Rolla says "We expect it to be better on 965 in about 2 weeks.  If Jesse releases 2.2.1 before that, then 2.3 should include the major improvements."08:39
bryce"2.3 will release around march. 2.2.1 should be released near this month's end."08:39
tjaaltonhmm08:39
tjaaltonis March too late?08:39
tjaaltonhmm08:40
brycehmm, we were putting in new -ati's up until the last moment before release08:40
tjaaltonyeah.. but it was gutsy :)08:40
brycetrue08:40
bryceok I'll bring that up.08:40
brycewhat else?08:41
tjaaltonso 2.3 will use TTM, and we should be able to keep the hardy version more uptodate even when it's released08:43
tjaaltonI just hope they'll be around when the bugs keep rolling in :)08:43
bryceno kidding08:43
tjaaltonso _if_ we are able to use TTM for intel, we _could_ ship with 2.308:44
bryceare you certain 2.3 will require TTM?  I can ask to get clarification on that08:44
tjaaltonbut otherwise it's 2.2.1 and back to XAA08:44
tjaaltonoh, no I'm not sure, but if it's not available then we still have the annoying bugs08:45
* bryce nods08:45
bryceI'll ask for clarification on it08:45
bryceTTM is wholey within libdrm?  No xserver components needed?08:48
tjaaltonI'll probably take a C course this semester, which should improve my debugging skills :)08:48
brycewholly08:48
brycecool08:48
tjaaltonAIUI yes08:48
tjaaltonthe redirected direct rendering touches xserver08:49
tjaaltonbut that's separate08:49
bryceupstream would be very sad if we went back to XAA08:50
bryce"the gfx team says:08:50
bryceEXA should only be slower than XAA on 965 mostly.  Also, we're working08:50
brycefully on EXA and we're we are doing nothing else with XAA so it doesn't08:50
brycesupport other features we've added - thus reverting to XAA would leave08:50
bryceyou unsupported.08:50
bryce"08:50
tjaaltonyeah :/08:51
tjaaltoncarrot-and-stick08:51
bryceI sort of don't like how they flip switch over to new features and (relatively) immediately drop support for the old version08:52
brycereminds me of the -i810/-intel switch08:52
tjaaltontrue08:58
tjaaltondrm built with a couple of nouveau related warnings, nothing else08:58
brycetjaalton: are you experiencing bug 175774?  I also started noticing it recently.09:09
ubotuLaunchpad bug 175774 in xserver-xorg-video-intel "[hardy] Enabling "Normal" effects produces badly drawn window shadows." [Critical,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/17577409:09
bryceI assumed it was compiz' fault but see the bug has ended up with us09:09
bryceah nevermind, I see you've already commented on it09:09
tjaaltonyes, it's visible with EXA09:11
ubotuNew bug: #182489 in linux-restricted-modules-2.6.24 (restricted) "Atheros wireless (AR5006EG) not working on ASUS Eee PC" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/18248909:39
Ngthe gfx team are wrong, EXA is slower on 855 too ;)09:42
tjaaltonheh09:43
* Ng been playing with pm-utils quirks and I can kind of get X back after a resume, but scrolling is still very broken when I do, so it's clearly not working properly somewhere. I'm trying to find out what the correct suspend quirks are for this hardware and I was wondering if I could reasonably try the intel driver from gutsy-proposed with the hardy Xorg09:43
tjaaltonsure, the current version is, but the TTM version is 40% slower on 965 than a non-TTM version of the driver09:43
Ngouch09:43
tjaaltonrest should apparently be fine09:44
tjaalton..with TTM09:44
mvoNg: contracts for terminator being in the repository!09:44
NgI'm also considering pestering Peter Clifton about it, since he was so awesome in tracking down the bug that stopped me suspending with the release gutsy -intel driver09:44
Ngmvo: ta :D09:44
mvoNg: meh, make that congrats :)09:44
* mvo can't type09:44
NgI also need to find more brave x40 users :)09:46
mvoNg: dholbach comes to my mind09:48
Ngmvo: ooh, interesting point :)09:49
brycenight10:12
Ngcya bryce :)10:14
tjaaltonnight bryce, hopefully I'll have a working TTM setup by the time you wake up :)10:16
mvonight bryce10:31
mvotjaalton: do you happen to know aobut the latest development with the redirected direct rendering? is it merged into some branch already?10:32
tjaaltonmvo: I know that cworth is working on it, but at least his personal trees haven't been updated in a while, so could be that they are now in a separate branch (of xserver etc)10:34
tjaaltononce I get this TTM crap working I'll have a closer look10:35
mvook, thanks10:35
tjaaltonhmm strange.. emacs runs on a local display but not over ssh, fails with xcb_xlib_lock assertion11:34
tjaaltonand now it works11:35
tjaaltonpuzzling11:35
ubotuNew bug: #4596 in xorg (main) "Xorg 6.8.2-77 has multiple issues/bugs" [Undecided,Fix committed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/459612:12
sirex`How can I submit new keyboard layout to Ubuntu?12:18
tjaaltonsirex`: please submit them upstream12:38
tjaaltonfile a bug against xkeyboard-config on bugzilla.freedesktop.org12:39
sirex`Ok, thans tjaalton.12:39
tjaaltonsirex`: then if it is approved and included in upstream we can add it to our package12:43
sirex`tjaalton: can I sumbit a bug to bugs.launchpad.net?12:43
sirex`I mean bug about new keyboard layout..12:44
tjaaltonyes, and then link to the upstream bug12:44
tjaaltonso we know when it's applied upstream12:44
sirex`I filed bug: http://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1409613:11
ubotuFreedesktop bug 14096 in General "New Lithuanian keyboard layout LEKP" [Normal,New] 13:11
tjaaltonok, now file the same on lp.net, and link to the b.fd.o bug13:16
ubotuNew bug: #183511 in xkeyboard-config (main) "New keyboard layout – LEKP" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/18351113:21
tjaaltonsirex`: ok, I can link the upstream bug to that13:24
tjaaltondone13:25
Ngooooh14:21
NgI just got a successful suspend/resume cycle14:21
* Ng tries again14:21
tjaaltondon't spoil it :)14:22
Ngwin!14:22
Ngthat's so weird, but somehow the new kernel seems to have fixed that14:22
NgI noticed pitti said his suspend worked with it14:22
Ngnow I need to hack the hal fdi's to set the quirks for this laptop14:22
Ngand maybe try and whittle the list of required quirks down a bit14:22
Ngbut at least I can close out my bug14:26
seb128see you later18:16
Q-FUNKapparently, bartman's combined patch (port blacklist, pci listing, ubuntu changelog) on xserver-corg-core 1.3 (gutsy) has been verified to not introduce regressions when upgrading X under -intel.18:49
Q-FUNKI'm testing now with nv and siliconmotion18:49
Q-FUNK(and needless to say, with -amd too)18:52
Q-FUNKbryce: maybe it's just me, but these tow patches make this nv driver feel snappier.22:52
bryce:-)22:52
tjaaltonmesa head building.. I guess it'll take a while23:09
Q-FUNKmesa /bin/jarjarbinks ?23:11
tjaaltonnot quite as annoying to watch ;)23:13
Q-FUNK;)23:13
tjaaltonduh, failed23:15
tjaaltonat i915tex, the next one would've been i96523:16
tjaaltonthe one _I_ need23:16
tjaaltonsomething for tomorrow then..23:18
tjaalton->23:18
bryceheya tormod23:22
tormodhi bryce!23:22
tormodtesting out the new Render support on radeon. Any idea I what I can test for? compiz?23:23
brycetjaalton: I finally managed to get a good backtrace of the poulsbo ume crash - it's a ioctl call to the kernel.  So, something appears to be broken in the kernel.23:23
* tormod is starting to hate {trackerd,updatedb,scrollkeeper-update}23:26
bryceI may need to learn how to shut that off23:26
tormodthe killer is when I do a package update that calls scrollkeeper-in-hell-update and at the same time the cron job kicks in, and they starve each other :(23:28
Q-FUNKhow was it that I enable my PPA again?23:28
tormodfunny enough, it happens often on a slow machine, if you have the habit of updating just after booting.23:29
Q-FUNKI have test packages of the patched server for gutsy and of the latest amd, also backported for gutsy.23:29
tormodQ-FUNK: isn't that just a click on launchpad?23:29
Q-FUNKseems enabled, but no idea how to upload to it23:32
tormodQ-FUNK: dput23:32
tormodwhere is the blacklist for compiz located?23:32
Q-FUNKyes, but where to?23:32
Q-FUNKah. found23:34
* tormod thought he knew better than the blacklist...23:40

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.7 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!