/srv/irclogs.ubuntu.com/2009/06/10/#ubuntu-x.txt

Sarvatthmm think i stripped too much out of the livecd that time, kept crashing back to gdm login :P got the iso down to 446MB ripping out printing/scanning stuff though02:24
wesmohi all07:16
wesmoWhen trying to build the latest drm-modules source from https://launchpad.net/~xorg-edgers/+archive/ppa with "sudo module-assistant auto-install drm-modules"; the build fails07:19
wesmothe buildlog from /var/cache/modass/drm-modules-source.. is http://pastebin.com/m70a9e8bb07:21
wesmoany idea whats wrong?07:22
crevetteheya08:00
crevettewhen I used KMS this week-end with intel, I had the screen that became black during the boot process and I ws not able to see anything else. I am using plain karmic. What information would you need? (I don't have my laptop here) 08:03
jcristaucrevette: kernel log for a start08:58
crevettejcristau, okay09:30
crevetteI'll try to test KMS in the coming days to see if it happens again09:30
jcristauthis is using a stock kernel, not a self-compiled one, right?09:31
crevetteyep, all stock09:31
crevetteon https://wiki.ubuntu.com/X/KernelModeSetting you can look for bmillemathias09:31
jcristauso it could be misdetecting the connected outputs. and then turning off the lvds.09:31
crevettewhen I trying to switch vt, I was alble to seem some text on the vt5 IIRC09:32
seb128on what package do you suggest opening a bug about xorg crashing on jaunty intel when playing some videos?10:13
seb128the server or the intel driver rather?10:13
tjaaltonintel I think. although there probably are dupes in the 300 open bugs ;)10:14
Ngthe uds spec for karmic xorg plans gives the impression that apart from xserver 1.7, the merges are generally done at this point :o10:50
Ngassuming I'm reading that right, that rocks :)10:50
tjaaltonNg: we still need a newer mesa, and the nouveau version is obsolete12:08
Ngit all seems to be in pretty good shape to me :)12:08
tjaaltonI'll try to remember that in late September ;)12:09
jcristauyou're planning on mesa 7.6-ish?12:10
tjaaltonsomething like that12:10
tjaaltonI'd really like to see r6/7xx support in the dri driver, but it's the holiday season soon etc..12:11
tjaaltonunless it's going to be released as a bug-free driver :)12:12
Ngtjaalton: when I start screaming at the last minute because of bugs? ;)12:13
tjaaltonNg: gotcha :)12:14
Nghehe12:15
NgI'm running the dev version *way* earlier than usual, so hopefully I'll spot anything sooner :)12:15
NgI normally wait until a month before beta12:15
jcristautjaalton: ah yeah good point.  hopefully r6/7xx will be usable by then.12:16
jcristauif it's not, then it'll be usable by squeeze ;)12:16
tjaaltonjcristau: that's just my hopeful thinkin, fingers crossed13:41
tjaalton+g13:41
=== seb128_ is now known as seb128
=== crevette_ is now known as crevette
XCP2hi. there's a bug in xorg in the newer versions of ubuntu that has not been fixed. however, there is a PPA on launchpad that apparently fixes the problem (not in clean way, but it's okay for me). Now my question: if I apply this PPA patch and some time later there is an official ubuntu patch for this problem, or any other update to xorg, will and can this newer update still be applied, although I manually changed my xorg some time before?17:02
jcristaui guess it depends on the version number in the ppa17:02
XCP2jcristau: here's the link. (how would I find out the version number from it?) https://edge.launchpad.net/~ubuntu-x-swat/+archive/xserver-no-backfill ... it fixes a problem in xorg, which causes xorg to use up 6GB+ memory after a while and take it 3-4 seconds to maximize a single window, each time leaking memory.. 17:03
XCP2this bug has actually haunted me and other users for 2 months now, and I finally found this unofficial patch (because the official developers seem to see no reason to fix it)17:04
jcristauthe description on that ppa doesn't sound like it has anything to do with a memory leak17:04
XCP2jcristau: yes, this is misleading, I know. it actually reverts a patch that causes this memory leak.17:04
XCP2jcristau: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/fglrx-installer/+bug/351186?comments=all17:05
ubottuLaunchpad bug 351186 in fglrx-installer "[ubuntu 9.04] slow unminimizing with ati card and desktop effects enabled" [Undecided,Confirmed]17:05
jcristauno it doesn't.17:05
XCP2jcristau: according to the patch author, it does17:05
jcristau*shrug*17:06
jcristauanyway yeah, if there's an update in jaunty proper, it will take precedence over this package17:06
XCP2so the answer to my original question is 'yes'? I can install this PPA and still have my xorg be properly updated later by ubuntu?17:07
jcristauyes17:08
XCP2thank you, jcristau. :)17:08
XCP2I don't want to be importunately or something, but this bug is known for over 2 months now, it has 3 duplicates, and as you can see a lot of affected users. it really is a very annoying bug which seriously hinders usage of a system. how come this still isn't fixed? I cannot see any information on why it is taking so long.17:09
Sarvattbecause there are even more people broken and just as annoying by disabling it most likely :) (aka all kubuntu users)17:10
Sarvattjust as annoyed*17:10
XCP2Sarvatt: please say again? what do you mean? 17:11
Sarvatthttp://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=17046217:11
ubottuKDE bug 170462 in compositing "Video garbage when drawing new object (Comment #54)" [Normal,Resolved: downstream]17:12
Sarvatthttps://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/xorg/+bug/31022817:12
ubottuLaunchpad bug 310228 in xorg "patch 107_fedora_dont_backfill_bg_none.patch causes video garbage in KDE 4 (dup-of: 254468)" [Undecided,New]17:12
ubottuLaunchpad bug 254468 in xorg-server "MASTER: momentary video garbage upon drawing new objects (particularly in KDE)" [High,Confirmed]17:12
XCP2oh, I get what you mean... but then again, you can have the patch to the KDE problem AND patch the patch :) it's not like the only solution is to revert the patch.17:12
jcristauit's the one that's available today17:14
jcristauand since this isn't a high priority thing..17:14
XCP2jcristau: no offense, but if you had this problem yourself, you would certainly think otherwise. it is very annoying, my system crashes every so often because xorg becomes a memory hog, and whenever I maximize windows I have to wait for 3-4 seconds. I'd rather have video garbage than this.17:15
jcristauXCP2: the no-backfill patch doesn't change memory usage.17:18
XCP2jcristau: have you test it yourself? do you have an ATI card?17:23
jcristauno, and no17:23
XCP2then how do you know? :)17:24
jcristaubecause i've seen the patch?17:24
XCP2jcristau: maybe the change in memory usage & behavior is just a side effect, not visible in the code. 17:25
XCP2but, that's just a guess.17:26
XCP2jcristau: from what I understand, the backfill patch itself leaks memory and therefore applying the no-blackfill patch reverts that behavior.17:27
jcristausounds like a driver bug to me...17:28
XCP2maybe, but I used the same official ATI driver on 8.04 & 9.04... on 8.04 it does not happen, on 9.04 it leaks.17:28
XCP2still, can be a driver issue, but I think it's rather unlikely.17:28
lesshasteany cuda users here?17:43
jbarnes_PDXbryce or apw: who should I harass about bluetooth stuff?19:21
superm1jbarnes_PDX, what about bluetooth stuff?19:26
superm1i happen to touch it a lot, but i dont pretend to know everything about it :)19:27
jbarnes_PDXsuperm1: oh cool19:34
jbarnes_PDXwith karmic bluetooth bits (gnome-bluetooth & pulse stuff)19:34
jbarnes_PDXa2dp *almost* works automatically19:34
superm1jbarnes_PDX, that's great to hear!19:35
superm1what's the "almost" tho ;)19:36
jbarnes_PDXwell sometimes it doesn't pair19:36
jbarnes_PDXand it also doesn't work with skype (with karmic bits skype no longer lists "pulse" as an option)19:36
superm1isn't default equivalent to pulse though?19:37
jbarnes_PDXalso with the pulse dev chooser I'd expect my headset to show up as a new sink19:37
jbarnes_PDXprobably should be, but doesn't work19:37
jbarnes_PDXand finally, when switching profiles, between a2dp and headset, I need to unpair and pair again, which seems wrong19:37
jbarnes_PDXit's cool to be able to listen to music, but I'd like for everything to "just work"19:38
superm1yeah i agree, yeah that does seem wrong19:38
jbarnes_PDXideally, I turn on my headset and a dialog pops up "wanna use this?  as a headset or stereo headphones?"19:38
jbarnes_PDXand takes care of the rest (making it default in pulse, moving my streams over, etc)19:39
jbarnes_PDXI guess I'll chat with marcel about which bits I ought to use, then file bugs in launchpad19:39
superm1unfortunately marcel doesn't use an upstream tracker at all19:40
superm1he browses launchpad every so often, but doesn't commit to fixing bugs19:41
jbarnes_PDXright19:41
jbarnes_PDXbrb19:41
superm1how do you switch profiles on your headset? is it a little switch?19:41
jbarnes_PDXsuperm1: no, pulse lets me choose19:48
jbarnes_PDXsuperm1: but my headset doesn't need to repair afaik19:49
jbarnes_PDXmy phone can switch profiles pretty easily at least... it doesn't take long19:49
superm1ah that's surprising. i didn't realize that the pulse plugin was that feature filled19:50
crevettesuperm1: latest pulseaudio make audio over bluetooth quite easy19:51
crevette:)19:51
superm1oh hai crevette19:52
crevettehey hey superm119:52
superm1do you follow linux-bluetooth@vger?19:52
crevetteubuntu-x became the lair for bluetooth discussion ?19:52
jbarnes_PDXcrevette: yeah it's really close to being nice19:52
superm1haha19:52
jbarnes_PDXcrevette: heh19:52
crevettesuperm1: unfortunately I lack time to19:52
jbarnes_PDXprobably #ubuntu-desktop would be better?19:52
crevette:)19:52
superm1crevette, okay well i was gonna let you know, i talked to petr @ redhat, and that ondemand stuff is going upstream19:53
superm1so lets wait in ubuntu until it's ready upstream19:53
crevettesuperm1: ah I see you asked that on the IRC chan few days ago19:53
crevetteah wonderful19:53
superm1i did?  I spoke to him over email i thought..19:53
crevetteI've opened a but in debian because I was thinking to merge our delta with debian package19:54
crevettesuperm1:you did :)19:54
superm1actually i think we can sync to debian19:54
superm1i reviewed the delta yesterday, and it looks like everything we have is useless right now delta wise19:54
crevettesuperm1: there is no change to keep on ubuntu side?19:54
superm1i just want to test their hid2hci changes19:54
superm1hid2hci is where i invested my blood in bluez, so if we sync and that breaks, i think i'll cry19:55
crevettemy knowledge in blueooth is quite ... low, so as does it does, switching hid devices to another mode?19:55
crevettes/so as does it does/so what does it does.19:56
jbarnes_PDXI'm not sure19:56
superm1some bluetooth devices support a mode that doesn't expose a BT radio, but instead lets a pre-paired keyboard and mouse work 19:56
jbarnes_PDXI don't know if it has to renegotiate the link or just tell the dev to switch profiles19:56
superm1all "newish" dell devices start up in this mode. i wrote some patches to hid2hci to get them back19:56
jbarnes_PDXoh hid devices19:57
superm1how its done for different BT chips is proprietary on a vendor by vendor basis19:57
superm1generally if you are using a hid device in hid mode and then want to use the hid device in hci mode too, you will have to renegotiate the link19:58
brycejbarnes, heya20:01
jbarnes_PDXbryce: howdy20:01
brycebtw, I sent a couple bugs upstream yesterday, but interestingly I found that pretty much all the UXA, KMS, 2.6.30, 2.6.99* bugs in our tracker seem to already be upstream near as I can tell20:02
bryceso... that's good news... sounds like most everything that's worth caring about at the moment is upstreamed20:02
jbarnes_PDXyeah that's great20:02
brycehowever I still need to do my script thingee to ask everyone to re-test.  gonna work on that today20:02
jbarnes_PDXbryce: has a kernel landed in xorg edgers yet?20:03
brycewe've got a few kernels bouncing around in ppas, but not in xorg-edgers so far20:04
bryceapw has been working on one with nouveau and ati bits merged in20:04
brycejbarnes, is there a particular kernel you think we should pull into xorg-edgers?20:04
jbarnes_PDXcool20:04
Sarvattkernel for what?20:04
bryceheya Sarvatt20:04
jbarnes_PDXbryce: I was hoping for something with drm-intel-next merged into it20:04
Sarvattheyo!20:04
bryceahh20:05
bryceI'll try to remember to ask apw if he'd be able to produce one next time I see him20:05
lesshasteanyone here got cuda to work?20:06
brycelesshaste: nope20:06
* apw is just off, if you email me a reminder i'll have a peek tomorrow. it may be hard to give you just one kernel for all of those on an on going basis if they collide, but i can try it out20:06
apwbryce, ^^20:06
bryceapw: cool, will send an email later today20:07
lesshastebryce, :( did you try?20:07
Sarvattdrm-intel-next drm-radeon-merge and newttm for nouveau dont all merge right now :(20:07
apwcirtianly i had to work hard to get the latter two to merge last time20:08
apwthose gem guys need to get their heads together!20:08
brycelesshaste: no, I'm pretty sure no one on this channel has experimented with it, so this may not be the optimal place for discussion on it20:08
lesshastebryce, ah20:08
lesshastebryce, it's very hard to find anyone who has got it working to be honest20:08
lesshasteas in so far I have found exactly no one20:08
brycelesshaste: maybe you'll become the definitive source if you write a good blog post on it ;-)20:09
lesshasteeverything could be solved if there was a package for cuda in a repository20:09
lesshastebut I can't find one20:09
lesshastebryce, :)20:09
Sarvatti saw a PPA for cuda a few months ago20:09
lesshasteSarvatt, ooh!!20:09
lesshasteI searched for the word cuda but didn't see it20:10
lesshasteany idea how to find this?20:10
crevettesuperm1: do you want to package 4.41? or do you prefer me to do it?20:10
superm1crevette, after i check debian's package w/ hid2hci on karmic, i think we can just ask debian to do it20:10
superm1and sync from them instead20:10
superm1did you see anything in the delta from debian that we needed to keep?20:11
crevettesuperm1: when you say "ask debian to do it" you mean slap filippo until he did it?20:11
crevette:)20:11
superm1exactly20:11
crevettelet ask to sync on it once debian has it20:14
lesshasteSarvatt, any ideas? I only see things like https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/20350320:15
ubottuLaunchpad bug 203503 in ubuntu "[needs-packaging] cuda packages" [Wishlist,Confirmed]20:15
Sarvattlesshaste: http://forums.nvidia.com/index.php?showtopic=93535 ?20:15
lesshasteSarvatt, thanks.. that's the painful route I have been trying20:16
lesshasteyou just feel envyng should do this for you20:16
lesshastehmm.. maybe it does secretly20:21
lesshastewill check tomorrow20:21
bryceSarvatt: have you had a chance to test the kernel at https://edge.launchpad.net/~apw/+archive/daily ?20:22
Sarvattare you just trying to run cuda apps? because the cuda libs should be installed by the driver, the guide is just for installing the SDK to develop against..20:22
bryceI'm thinking of pulling it into xorg-edgers.  I've tested it on several different video cards, and think it could be useful for further KMS work in X.org, but what do you think?20:23
Sarvatti dont think its really compatable with putting in edgers right now because it has radeon KMS enabled by default and the drm/ddx parts arent compatable with the packages on there20:25
bryceok20:26
Sarvatti guess we could start shipping libdrm-radeon1 in libdrm though.. but the ati ddx is kind of a regression from master for non KMS stuff, i'm not sure if it'd require us to start merging radeon-rewrite with master on mesa on top of that too20:27
Sarvattreally though, not much point IMO because the KMS stuff has already been presented for proposal in 2.6.31 a few hours ago, hope they clean up the libdrm stuff soon20:29
lesshastebryce, I see you are involved in envyng?20:29
lesshastebryce, where is the #envy channel?20:29
lesshasteunless there is another bryce :)20:30
lesshastetseliot, hi20:30
tseliotlesshaste: hi20:31
lesshastetseliot, I wanted to ask an envyng question.. if you don't mind20:31
tseliotlesshaste: shoot20:31
lesshasteI am trying to get cuda to work and have been struggling all day20:32
lesshasteenvyng installs 173.x I think  hardy20:32
lesshastewhich doesn't seem compatible with the cuda sdk you can download from nvidia20:32
lesshastebut I may have this messed up20:32
lesshastedo you think that it's possible to get cuda working with the version of the nvidia driver envyng gives you?20:32
Sarvattyeah thats not compatable, they didnt make the drivers cuda compatable until the 180's20:33
lesshastebut envyng does give you a cuda library file20:33
lesshasteso I am confused20:33
tseliotlesshaste: cuda in 173?20:34
lesshasteI went in so many circles today I may have this wrong20:34
lesshastetseliot, so let's scrap my ignorance just ask the key question20:34
lesshastecould you please make an envyng version that also installs cuda :)20:34
lesshasteas it is killing me20:34
lesshasteI installed the later nvidia driver20:34
lesshastebut I really can't get cuda to work20:34
Sarvattahh sorry, i thought it was 180's only for some reason, maybe that was the case on windows or something because thats the only place i've messed with the cuda sdk20:35
lesshasteI see http://albertomilone.com/wordpress/?p=148 .. which seems to say to me that envy does provide cuda now20:36
lesshasteI am so confused :)20:36
tseliotlesshaste: the packages provide cuda. Maybe install the -dev package of the nvidia driver (the -envy flavour)?20:37
bryceheya tseliot20:38
lesshastetseliot, ok so once I have installed should I be able to compile the cuda SDK?20:38
lesshastetseliot, because I feel it failed today20:38
tseliothi bryce20:38
lesshasteor can envy get  a version of the SDK that works too?20:39
tseliotlesshaste: I guess so. Make sure you uninstall the driver that you installed from the nvidia installer first or you'll end up with a mess20:39
tseliotlesshaste: Envy doesn't get the SDK20:39
lesshastetseliot, ok.. what's the best way to uninstall the driver from nvidia?20:40
lesshasteah.. maybe nvidia-installer --uninstall20:41
tseliotlesshaste: have a look at point B of the FAQ: http://albertomilone.com/envyngfaq.html#B20:41
lesshastetseliot, thanks.. I don't have the computer here now but will try it all tomorrow.. especially compiling the sdk20:42
lesshastetseliot, will you be about at all tomorrow?20:42
lesshasteso I can thank you :)20:42
lesshastealso, perhaps some words about cuda could be added to the FAQ?20:43
lesshastefor dumb people like me20:43
tseliotlesshaste: yes, even though it's 21:43 here now and I don't work at this time. But my computer is always on ;)20:43
lesshastetseliot, mine too :)20:43
lesshasteit's 20:43 here20:43
lesshastetseliot, the point is that the web is full of detailed instructions for how to get cuda to work in ubuntu and..20:44
lesshastea) they don't work20:44
lesshasteand b) they don't mention envyng 20:44
tseliotlesshaste: I don't use it, therefore I wouldn't be comfortable with writing instructions for the things that I've never tried20:44
tseliotI made sure that the libcuda.so, etc. were provided by the packages20:45
lesshastetseliot, ah ok.. I'll let you know what happens when I try it in that case20:45
lesshasteif you are interested20:45
tseliotok20:45
lesshastetseliot, oh yes.. is there really a #envy channel somewhere?20:52
Sarvatthttp://lkml.org/lkml/2009/6/10/29420:54
tseliotlesshaste: no, I don't think there is one. I don't even have the time to maintain envy anymore20:54
lesshastetseliot, ah ok.. there is an irc log https://wiki.ubuntu.com/EnvyNG20:56
lesshasteit must be faked :)20:56
Sarvattwhy dont you just use the binary drivers from nvidia lesshaste? only issue with those is having to reinstall them every kernel upgrade, but how often do you get kernel upgrades still on hardy?20:56
lesshasteSarvatt, well.. let me tell you :)20:56
lesshasteSarvatt, I did exactly that and installed 185.18.0820:57
lesshasteI think compiled the SDK as per instructions20:57
lesshasteand when I run any cuda sample I get20:57
Sarvattthose had a library problem screwing up some mesa things that got fixed in .14 i think20:57
lesshastecutilCheckMsg() CUTIL CUDA error: cudaMalloc failed in file20:57
lesshaste<fluidsGL_kernels.cu>, line 49 : initialization error.20:57
lesshasteor equivalent20:57
tseliotlesshaste: what card are you using?20:58
lesshasteSarvatt, http://www.nvidia.com/object/cuda_get.html offers only 185.18.08 as the latest version20:58
lesshastetseliot, geforce 620020:58
Sarvatt.....20:59
Sarvattyou know those dont  support cuda right20:59
lesshasteerr..20:59
Sarvatt8xxx and up..20:59
lesshasteno!!20:59
lesshasteI had no idea20:59
lesshasteI feel quite depressed now 21:00
tseliotSarvatt: are you sure? He's talking about CUDA not VDPAU21:00
Sarvattyeah positive, even the site he linked shows it requiring 8xxx and up21:00
Sarvatthttp://www.nvidia.com/object/cuda_learn_products.html21:00
tseliotaah, you need the latest driver to use the latest version of CUDA21:01
Sarvatthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CUDA21:01
SarvattThe latest drivers all contain the necessary CUDA components. CUDA works with all NVIDIA GPUs from the G8X series onwards, including GeForce, Quadro and the Tesla line.21:02
lesshastewell.. what an idiot!!21:02
tseliotyou're right. I thought it was just VDPAU that required newer cards21:03
tseliotproblem solved then ;)21:03
tseliotwell, kind of21:03
* tseliot > away21:03
lesshastesorry everyone for that21:04
lesshasteI wasted quite a lot of time :)21:04
lesshasteSarvatt, thanks21:04
bryceNg: hey, quick question on your 8xx system - does it have an S-Video (TV-out) port?  If so, would you mind testing at some point when it's convenient if it does not work on jaunty, and then test karmic alpha-2 as well?  I'm looking at bug 6270 (currently the lowest-numbered X bug report yay), and wondering if the problem is going to still be a problem with the new stack.21:45
ubottuLaunchpad bug 6270 in xserver-xorg-video-intel "[i855] no support for TV-Out on 8xx chipsets" [Unknown,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/627021:45
Ngbryce: 'fraid not, just LCD and VGA21:57
bryceNg: ok thanks21:57
lesshastewhat's the easiest way to get a dual head setup in ubuntu?22:30
lesshastebasically, what card do I need to buy?22:30
brycelesshaste: I have an ATI X1650 that is quite easy to configure23:02
brycelesshaste: I'd recommend any ATI in the R5xx class23:02
brycebe aware that R600 and newer are not supported as well by the open source driver, but 6xx/7xx cards are the most common in stores these days, so it takes some hunting to find a suitable R5xx card23:03
lesshastethanks23:03
bryceIntel 945 and 965 are also good choices, but only come on motherboards23:03
brycewith nvidia, I've heard good things about 8800 GTS, however pretty much with nvidia you're still limited to the proprietary driver only23:04
bryceI've heard 8800 works with -nouveau, and in fact I've put in an order for one in order to check that out.23:04

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.7 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!