/srv/irclogs.ubuntu.com/2010/09/16/#ubuntu-x.txt

Sarvattstill a big range between there to bisect down more00:00
brycehyeah but we can probably rule a lot of stuff out00:01
brycehlike... there's a ton of glsl stuff, that's not going to be relevant right?00:01
brycehoh wow, one of the patches in this set was one of the mildly suspicious anholt ones...  50a3349bee04088bee3491622d6ef3c032d01eac00:03
Sarvattyeah and nothing with st/foo00:03
brycehmesa: Set the base format of GL_ALPHA FBOs and teach swrast about it.00:03
brycehthe error message you and I are seeing has to do with GL ALPHA's (that's the 21 at the end of the message I gather)00:03
brycehhowever there's nothing *obviously* wrong with that patch00:04
brycehjust that it's returning GL_ALPHA now in cases where it didn't, and 00:04
brycehand at the point where we're getting that error message it's receiving alpha it isn't set up to deal with00:04
brycehSarvatt, btw any idea what the FS stuff anholt's working on is?00:05
SarvattMesa 7.9-devel implementation error: Bad renderbuffer format: 2100:05
SarvattPlease report at bugzilla.freedesktop.org00:05
Sarvatt(unity:9658): libunity-private-DEBUG: test-window.vala:295: This target does not support getting window details00:05
Sarvatt** (unity:9658): DEBUG: Active window is: NULL00:05
Sarvatt** (unity:9658): DEBUG: Switching to menus from XID 000:05
Sarvatt** (unity:9658): DEBUG: Looking for parent window on XID 5662310700:05
Sarvatt** (unity:9658): DEBUG: Switching to menus from XID 5662310700:05
Sarvatt** (unity:9658): DEBUG: Unable to get MWM functions for: 5662310700:05
Sarvattthat message is there during all the good builds too00:05
brycehwondering if those can all be ignored00:06
brycehoh00:06
Sarvattyeah they can  be ignored, it's all hidden behind an env variable to use it00:06
brycehrats, then so much for my theory00:06
brycehbut if it at all matters, I think that error message is caused by not supporting the MESA_FORMAT_A8 in the i915 code.  The support's there for 965 tho (which is probably why kenvandine doesn't see the warning)00:07
brycehSarvatt, so maybe next step would be to extract out all the glx patches from the 908 snapshot and see if the issue goes away00:08
brycehwe kinda suspect glx, and that would narrow it down to a small set of patches00:08
Sarvatti'm checking 0915 now incase http://cgit.freedesktop.org/mesa/mesa/commit/?id=4ebf07a426771b62123e5fcb5a8be0de24037af1 fixes00:10
Sarvattno dice00:10
brycehSarvatt, if you post the 0908 packages I can work on extracting the glx patches00:11
brycehotherwise I should take care of some uploads for cnd00:11
Sarvatthttp://sarvatt.com/downloads/bryce/00:13
brycehkenvandine, you still around?03:16
brycehguess not03:52
brycehkenvandine, anyway I've fixed the bug, would be nice to get confirmation on your hw03:52
Dinkbryceh, if you need to test it on 945GME I can be the guinea pig04:21
brycehDink, go ahead05:06
kamstrupbryceh,  is there some special repo i need in order to test out mesa_7.9~git20100909-0ubuntu2?08:28
brycehkamstrup, no08:31
kamstrupbryceh, ok, holding on for it to hit the updates then :-)08:33
RAOFbryceh: Good morning.08:59
brycehhi RAOF08:59
RAOFI understand that mesa 7.9 broke unity?09:00
brycehyep09:00
RAOFBecause of bug #632352 ?09:00
ubot4Launchpad bug 632352 in clutter-1.0 (Ubuntu) "Clutter fails to update with Mesa 7.9 (affects: 1) (heat: 10)" [Critical,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/63235209:00
RAOFWhich I hadn't noticed hadn't been uploaded?09:02
brycehmaybe; certainly it is some sort of bad state of drawables.  I found that reverting the drawable garbage collector made the issue resolve09:03
brycehor at least, unity drew itself.09:04
RAOFI'll have a look at the patches you reverted and see if one of them contains the same thing.09:04
brycehno09:05
brycehthe patches I reverted just swapped out the new garbage collector for the old crufty one09:05
brycehso my guess is that this merely sweeps the problem under the rug09:05
brycehiow the old gc may be sloppy and letting broken code get away with stuff09:06
RAOFPossibly.09:06
brycehthis clutter patch may be a more proper fix09:06
RAOFIt certainly fixes *a* all-white-screen bug; I hadn't noticed that it hadn't been uploaded because I've been running those clutter packages while testing 7.9!09:07
brycehon the other hand, if the new garbage collector is this brittle maybe that's ungood by itself09:07
RAOFIt's not brittle; it's that clutter was depending on a mesa bug that got fixed.09:07
brycehrah roah09:07
brycehheh09:08
RAOF(IE: it was relying on mesa always sending swap events even when they hadn't been asked for)09:08
brycehwow, well that'd be quite exasperating to know I wasted a day chasing down an X fix for something that's really a clutter fault!09:09
RAOFAnd when that bug got fixed in 7.9, the clutter mainloop no longer advances, because Unity doesn't ask for swap_events, so it doesn't recieve them, so clutter never advances the mainloop.09:09
brycehah09:10
brycehso with the bugged mesa what happens, is it that invalid code sends out events?09:10
RAOFYeah.  Prior to 7.9 mesa would unconditionally send out a bunch of events (invalidate, swap_complete, etc).09:11
brycehcommit f24ec6367b1cf6c6822fa998df8a87728871142709:12
brycehAuthor: Kristian Høgsberg <krh@bitplanet.net>09:12
brycehDate:   Wed Sep 8 18:54:30 2010 -040009:12
bryceh    glx: Ignore DRI2 event for drawables we've destroyed09:12
bryceh    09:12
bryceh    Since we now actually destroy GLX drawables, we get into situations where09:12
bryceh    we get events for drawables that no longer exist.  Just ignore the09:12
bryceh    event in that case.09:12
brycehthen that might be the relevant one of the three09:12
brycehalthough I had found if that was reverted but not 16887d042a917fa4773e4d853f50051b54e9948c as well, it still failed09:13
RAOFYeah.  You could also have reverted:09:13
RAOFcommit f8d81c31cee30821da3aab331a57f484f6a07a5d09:13
RAOFAuthor: Nick Bowler <nbowler@draconx.ca>09:14
RAOFDate:   Wed Jul 14 12:01:49 2010 -040009:14
RAOF    dri2: Track event mask in client code.09:14
RAOF    09:14
RAOF    When direct rendering is being used, DRI2 BufferSwapComplete events are09:14
RAOF    sent unconditionally to clients, even if they haven't been requested.09:14
RAOF    This causes error messages to be printed by every freeglut application09:14
RAOF    of the form09:14
RAOF    09:14
RAOF      freeglut (./gears): Unknown X event type: 10409:14
RAOF    09:14
RAOF    and might confuse other clients.09:14
RAOF    09:14
RAOF    This is a fixed up version of the patch by Jesse Barnes, which drops09:14
RAOF    BufferSwapComplete events if they are not requested by clients.09:14
RAOF    09:14
RAOF    Fixes fdo bug 27962.09:14
ubot4Launchpad bug 27962 in gnome-system-tools (Ubuntu) "The generate random password is invalid (heat: 2)" [Medium,Invalid] https://launchpad.net/bugs/2796209:14
RAOF    09:14
RAOF    Signed-off-by: Nick Bowler <nbowler@draconx.ca>09:14
RAOF    Signed-off-by: Jesse Barnes <jbarnes@virtuousgeek.org>09:14
brycehslow wireless? ;-)09:14
RAOFSlow wireless → my server in .au → you in US :)09:15
tjaaltonlet's add this to the wiki http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs713.snc4/63370_436968843916_823908916_5119505_7805897_n.jpg09:16
brycehtjaalton, lol09:17
RAOFHeh.09:17
brycehnew stock reply time09:18
tjaaltonyep :)09:18
brycehtjaalton, you at xds too?09:19
tjaaltonbryceh: nah09:20
tjaaltonoh, phoronix finally has something about xds..09:21
brycehthe wayland/meego bit?09:24
tjaaltonyep09:25
cndRAOF, I've pushed a new update to evdev: http://git.debian.org/?p=users/corp186-guest/xserver-xorg-input-evdev.git;a=shortlog;h=refs/heads/ubuntu09:42
cndI think a verbal (or over IRC :) ok would suffice for me to ask seb128 or didrocks to upload09:43
RAOFcnd: K.  Are you pushing to your private tree rather than pkg-xorg/xserver-xorg-input-evdev for some deep purpose? :)09:44
brycehapparently to confuse me09:44
cndRAOF, I don't want to push to the real tree until I get an ok09:44
cndbryceh, hey09:44
cnddidn't expect you up at this hour09:44
RAOFGah!09:44
RAOFWhy can't I pull from git?09:45
brycehcnd, drank too much coffee today chasing a mesa bug09:45
cndbryceh, heh09:45
* RAOF is terribly sorry about that!09:45
cndbryceh, so the evdev change didn't work09:45
cndyour upload put my changes, a debdiff, as a source patch :)09:45
brycehyeah looks like09:45
brycehI was squeezing that in between mesa builds, obviously didn't check close enough09:46
cndbryceh, np09:46
brycehcnd, for future reference it'd help to either have the stuff committed directly to the ubuntu evdev tree, or posted as a debdiff, or just having the straight patch.09:47
cndbryceh, my thought was that you could just git pull09:47
brycehevidently anything different from that just confuses me ;-)09:47
cndor cherry pick09:47
cndbut I can push directly to the real tree09:47
brycehyeah... I'm just real sucky at git09:47
cndheh09:47
soreauCan I get anyone running latest X bits to test compiz wallpaper? It has been broke and I am trying to determine if its fixed by a recent commit http://cgit.freedesktop.org/xorg/xserver/commit/?id=648c8871c92727d7b6b16859f27f12266a06a16e09:47
soreauOr if anyone has also experienced compiz wallpaper drawing nothing09:48
cndbryceh, I come from the kernel world where the mechanisms of code commit are different09:48
brycehyeah09:48
brycehwhat about the synaptics upload, was that ok?09:49
cndbryceh, looks like it09:49
RAOFI merged that into git, so I hope so :)09:49
brycehRAOF, the evdev patch?09:50
brycehyep09:50
brycehRAOF, are you going to upload it?09:51
brycehRAOF, or do you need me to?09:51
RAOFI need you too.09:51
RAOFBut I'll just test build first!09:51
brycehok, I'm ready to upload on your signal09:52
brycehcnd, sorry I've not been paying as much attention to mt as I had, it hit my annoyance threshold.09:57
cndbryceh, yeah, sorry10:11
cndit's really hitting my annoyance threshold too...10:12
cndbryceh, RAOF says everything is ok for upload10:15
cndhis irc client isn't working quite right10:19
cndhe blames the dx team :)10:19
jcristaueasy target10:21
brycehcnd, RAOF, okay uploaded.10:22
cndbryceh, thanks!10:23
brycehnp10:23
cndI'm really sorry about the fire drills and piling on10:23
cndand you should go get some sleep10:23
cnd:)10:23
brycehhehe, quite true10:23
brycehcnd, say hi to jbarnes for me10:24
WubbbiSarvatt: Is this Mesa update a fix for the clutter things?10:27
cndbryceh, will do10:28
kenvandinebryceh, yay!12:15
apwSarvatt, RAOF, did we used to carry some nvidia noaccel patches or am i on crack13:49
kenvandineSarvatt, bryceh's upload didn't fix the mesa/unity problem for me13:49
RAOFapw: We used to carry some nvidia noaccel patches; you're not on crack.13:49
kenvandineon my GM45 or 94513:50
kenvandinehey RAOF13:50
RAOFkenvandine: https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/clutter-1.0/+bug/63235213:50
ubot4Launchpad bug 632352 in clutter-1.0 (Ubuntu) "Clutter fails to update with Mesa 7.9 (affects: 1) (heat: 10)" [Critical,Confirmed]13:50
RAOFDoes that fix it?13:50
kenvandineRAOF, i didn't test that... missed that in reading the scrollback13:51
apwRAOF, so i got a report that a mac is showing the behaviour again on beta, noaccell fixes it 13:51
apwbug #54639313:52
ubot4Launchpad bug 546393 in linux (Ubuntu Lucid) (and 2 other projects) "MacBook Pro 5,1 / 5,2 / 5,3 / 5,5 fails to boot into 10.04 desktop (affects: 17) (dups: 1) (heat: 96)" [High,Fix released] https://launchpad.net/bugs/54639313:52
=== njpatel_ is now known as njpatel
RAOFapw: Hm.  So, have we lost the noaccel blacklist?13:59
RAOFDBO: Hey!  You're probably hitting bug #632352.  Want to check out the fix from there?14:00
ubot4Launchpad bug 632352 in clutter-1.0 (Ubuntu) "Clutter fails to update with Mesa 7.9 (affects: 1) (heat: 10)" [Critical,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/63235214:00
kenvandineRAOF, ok, testing that clutter... /me crosses fingers14:06
kenvandineRAOF, yay!14:08
kenvandinethat worked for me14:08
RAOFGood!14:09
RAOFThat'll be needing an upload, then :)14:09
kenvandineRAOF, any reason not to upload that?14:09
kenvandinei can do it :)14:09
kenvandinewant me to?14:10
RAOFYes, please.14:10
kenvandinecool14:10
kenvandinethx man!14:10
RAOFWe should revert the mesa bandaid, too.14:13
RAOFapw: It looks like we have lost noaccel blacklist from the kernel.14:15
apwRAOF, hrmphs14:17
apwi'll find out about iot14:17
kenvandineRAOF, can you upload the reverted bandaid to the ppa for testing?14:21
RAOFCertainly.14:21
kenvandinethx14:22
* kenvandine is scared :)14:22
kenvandineRAOF, actually... that would be basically exactly the mesa we had yesterday right?14:24
kenvandinei can test that easily14:24
RAOFkenvandine: It would indeed be exactly yesterday's mesa.14:25
kenvandineok... let me test that quickly14:25
kenvandinecan you prepare the source upload?14:25
kenvandineand can you upload after it is tested? i don't think i can upload X packages14:25
RAOFI can't upload it, either.14:28
kenvandineok, we can find a sponsor... just prepare it :)14:29
* kenvandine will brb... i hope14:29
kenvandine7.9~git20100909-0ubuntu114:30
kenvandineright?14:30
njpatelbryceh, RAOF, Sarvatt: btw, thanks for all the awesome work guys :)14:30
RAOFYup.14:30
apwRAOF, ok confirmed that we no longer have the noveau noaccel patches... s14:31
apws14:31
apwi assume we should only be reinstating them as we find confirmed requrements for them14:31
RAOFYeah, that'd be right.14:32
RAOFnjpatel: Sorry for breaking your baby :)14:32
njpatelRAOF, lol, one day I'll break X...and then you'll see! ;)14:33
apwRAOF, unfortuanatly we are already in RC freeze14:33
RAOFapw: And there are no more kernel uploads available! :(14:34
apwRAOF, as there is a noaccel on the command line work around i am unsure if its worth fighting the release team to get a spin14:34
RAOFIt's probably releasenotable.14:34
apwRAOF, not ideal for surew14:35
apwhrm14:35
apwwhy do people test on the freeze date, and then tell you its broken ?14:35
RAOFBecause they want it to work!14:36
apwheh not enough to test it when we might be able to do anything about it14:36
kenvandineRAOF, ok... it worked, mesa = 7.9~git20100909-0ubuntu1 with patched clutter works14:36
RAOFapw: Right.  If the tested it earlier, it might not work!14:36
apwheheh14:36
kenvandineRAOF, so YAY... lets get that uploaded14:37
Dinkhmm with the new fixes. Should ubuntu-netbook-default-settings be changed as well the clutter vbank = none ?15:25
kenvandineDink, i just uploaded a fix for that15:26
Dinkahh k15:26
kenvandinei had removed it from the package, but didn't rm it via postinst15:27
kenvandinesince it was a conffile15:27
Dinkso to test the new fix I should just rm it myself 15:27
Dinkthe 80lcutter_vblank_none file15:28
Dinkremoving the vblank=none I still get wsod15:44
Dink$ apt-cache policy libgl1-mesa-dri15:44
Dinklibgl1-mesa-dri:15:44
Dink  Installed: 7.9~git20100909-0ubuntu215:44
Dink  Candidate: 7.9~git20100909-0ubuntu215:44
Sarvattclutter-1.0 1.2.12-0ubuntu12 is what you need15:47
Dinklibclutter ? I do not see a clutter-1.015:49
Dinkthere is a clutter-1.0-tests15:49
Dink$ apt-cache policy libclutter-1.0-015:50
Dinklibclutter-1.0-0:15:50
Dink  Installed: 1.2.12-0ubuntu1115:50
Dinkhmm maybe it hasn't been published yet ?15:50
Dinkahh yeah I haven't gotten it yet in my repo15:52
Dinkswitching repos now15:53
Dinkhmm still nada getting it from launchpad15:56
Dinkbb going to test15:57
vishbryceh: have mercy on us! bug watcher is on a rampage.. :(  it is checking status for old fix released bugs too16:06
vishimportance rather...16:06
Dinkyay all working. The only strange part after I installed the latest ubuntu-netbook-default-settings it actually did not remove the existing 80clutter_vblank_none file even though it was not listed in the .deb16:08
Sarvatt<kenvandine> i had removed it from the package, but didn't rm it via postinst16:09
Sarvatt<kenvandine> since it was a conffile16:09
Sarvattthats what he meant by that :)16:09
Dinki thought that was the 0.8.7 release 16:10
Dinkahh its 0.8.816:10
DinkI see it now16:10
Dinkdamn builds in 4hrs16:11
Dinksorry for language16:12
Dinkslipped 16:12
Sarvattyeah everyones rushing to shove packages in before the final freeze in an hour or so :)16:14
DinkNow that things are a bit slow do you have a quick moment to check something out ?16:14
DinkI remove gnome-shell, gir1.0, and mesa-utils and my issue got better16:17
Dinkohh and libgq4 got upgraded during that time also. Something there helped.16:19
Dinklibgt4*16:19
=== yofel_ is now known as yofel
ScottKSarvatt or RAOF: Any hope for Bug #628077 getting fixed soonish?  I had thought you had a fix ~close at hand?16:35
ubot4Launchpad bug 628077 in xserver-xorg-video-intel (Ubuntu Maverick) (and 1 other project) "[i865] Crash on logout with KDM (affects: 1) (heat: 8)" [High,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/62807716:35
SarvattScottK: still working on it here but got caught up in the mesa mess, i'm sorry16:48
ScottKSarvatt: OK. /Thanks.16:48
Sarvattxserver-xorg-video-intel (2:2.12.0-1ubuntu61) maverick; urgency=low :D16:49
Sarvattugh, vblank interrupts are still horribly screwed on my netbook, things are jerky unless i move the mouse or disable it with a drirc17:17
Sarvattcould be the same thing that Wubbbi person was hitting yesterday, looks like its specific to these aspire ones17:19
* bryceh waves17:32
ScottKIs the reversion of the new mesa garbage collector going to get reverted now that clutter is (as I understand it) fixed?17:32
brycehvish, no mercy17:32
vish;p17:32
brycehvish, but it'll be over pretty soon, at least for gnome.  I'll probably kick off mozilla in a bit, that'll be another painful one17:33
vishyeah , gnome is that i get spammed..17:33
vishbryceh: but, why did the old fix released bugs need importance? it could have been blacklisted right?17:33
DinkSarvatt, runing aod250 myself and haven't noticed anything yet17:33
SarvattDink: run glxgears and dont touch the trackpad, it isn't choppy?17:35
ScottKbryceh: Would it be possible just not to send these emails?17:35
brycehvish, I suspect the reason for that is since they were closed the regular updater wasn't updating them, so when this change came through it decided to catch them all up17:35
vishlike Bug #181788 .. maybe something to consider for the other bug watches17:35
ubot4Launchpad bug 181788 in gtk+2.0 (Ubuntu Lucid) (and 6 other projects) "File chooser not working in current folder (affects: 23) (dups: 5) (heat: 148)" [Low,Fix released] https://launchpad.net/bugs/18178817:36
brycehScottK, not really, the launchpad code for doing the notices is pretty intricate and not configurable in that way17:36
Sarvattmy AOA150 starts thinking 15-18hz is the screen refresh rate if I dont move the mouse :)17:36
vishthe gtk task got closed as fixed on 8-31 so might be something else..17:36
ScottKbryceh: Then IMO the difficulty cause by this is more than the benefit of going back and fixing.17:37
brycehScottK, guess we can disagree there then17:37
vishalrighty.. back to X bisecting! :)17:38
ScottKbryceh: You probably didn't get caught away from home with only your phone to read email on and no good way to script dumping them all.17:38
DinkSarvatt, ahh yeah I see what you are saying. Yes same thing here. Also my other issue came back this time happend on just the netbook itself so it is not related to external monitor being plugged in.17:40
vishSarvatt: does your AOA on return from suspend immediately show the screen?  mine stays black and i need to move cursor17:40
SarvattDink: wget -O ~/.drirc http://sarvatt.com/downloads/drirc.txt17:41
DinkSarvatt, 110-120 without moving and about 280-300 moving it17:41
Sarvattvish: nope it doesn't but i dont use gnome-screensaver or screen locking at all so that might have something to do with it17:41
vishi dont lock either.. so might be screensaver..17:42
DinkSarvatt, wow soo much better17:42
Dink1040-1080 now17:43
Sarvattits not the fps i'm worried about17:43
Sarvattits fine that its lower, its just it thinks the screen refresh rate is like 15hz so things are choppy as heck17:43
Sarvattwonder if any non aspire one netbooks are hitting this too17:45
Sarvattack, that mesa revert didn't go in already?17:56
Sarvattguess it can wait for the next upload anyhow because we should have a RC release soon, trying to figure out what RAOF is doing with the git branches17:59
ScottKI may have another mesa change for you anyway.  Just uploaded a test package to my PPA.18:05
Sarvattoops, missed the new fglrx released yesterday, uploading to x-updates now19:54
Sarvattonly fix that isn't SUSE specific is - System no longer fails while launching fgl_glxgears window when Anti-Aliasing and Desktop Effects are enabled19:57
Sarvattbryceh: if you have a few moments to spare, would you be willing to look at this bug and tell me what you think regarding a SRU? https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/xserver-xorg-video-intel/+bug/64021423:01
ubot4Launchpad bug 640214 in xserver-xorg-video-intel (Ubuntu) (and 1 other project) "X failed on Intel B43 machine (affects: 2) (heat: 16)" [Undecided,New]23:01
Sarvattit's not urgent, i'm about to pass the heck out anyway :)23:01
brycehlooking23:29
brycehwill recognize -> will not recognize23:30
brycehThere's 5 patches, some of which arent' relevant, so I would suggest a) editing the non-relevant patches and remove their [x] patch flag, and b) explicitly linking the patch being proposed for sru in the description23:32
brycehSarvatt, the changes of adding pci ids seems quite sane, although the debdiff looks kinda weird, you might doublecheck that23:35
brycehSarvatt, but in general additions of pci ids to older releases is almost always fine for sru'ing23:35
brycehSarvatt, in fact we could probably be more aggressive at backporting pci ids in general, at least to the lts23:37
brycehSarvatt, yeah I'm kinda worn out still from yesterday myself 23:38
Sarvattbryceh: oh shoot, you're right, I didn't clean the tree before creating the package so it's got the diff in there twice, what a bonehead move :)23:41
brycehyeah removing the patch from debian/patches.  I've done that myself a time or two23:42
Sarvattand thats good to know, there are a bunch of ati ones to add to x-x-v-ati I think that i'll look into tomorrow23:43
brycehbet it'd build fine though, you don't need the patch after it's applied ;-)23:43
brycehthe first 2-3 ubuntu releases, following a release i'd just routinely snag all the new pci ids from each of the driver upstream git trees and do sru's23:44
brycehbut then it got so I just didn't have time, and often the newer hw required more than just pci ids anyway23:44
brycehbut those were always pretty straightforward sru's to get accepted23:44

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.7 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!