[00:09] jibel: reproduced (small silver lining, large cloud) [00:09] now let's see if it happens in qemu [00:24] jibel,skaet: I'm (a) confident I can fix this (b) doubtful I can do so in time for tomorrow [00:24] cjwatson, is there a workaround? or do we tell people not to use WUBI in the release notes? [00:25] I'm not sure, it's crashing in the grub configfile command [00:25] no obvious workaround, at least [00:25] I hate wubi [00:25] (but it's probably a GRUB bug) [00:25] * skaet is starting to get to that viewpoint as well - re WUBI [00:26] ok, we'll have to document it prominently that WUBI is not working quite yet [00:27] * jibel seconds cjwatson re hate wubi [00:27] skaet, or install maverick and upgrade to natty ;-) [00:27] I think it must be a memory allocation bug buried in grub somewhere [00:27] jibel: to me, there's no obvious reason why that wouldn't suffer from the same bug [00:27] except perhaps luck [00:28] I'm lucky then, upgrade passed on both arch [00:29] hmm, so we could see upgrade random failures crop up too... blech. [00:29] wubi in "random upgrade failure" shocker, film at 11 :-/ [00:30] * cjwatson goes and gets coffee before stepping through with gdb [00:30] cjwatson, thanks for figuring it out. [00:31] something similar actually happened to me when I was testing a previous fix, but when I tried to debug it, the bug ran away and hid and wouldn't come back out [00:31] so I concluded I must have hallucinated it somehow [00:31] but maybe this was the same thing; malloc arena corruption could explain it being a bit of a heisenbug [00:33] skaet, ok so here is the status for today: [00:33] * Image Coverage : 84.21% (64/76) [00:33] * Mandatory Test Cases : 86.94% (213/245) [00:33] * Run Once Test Cases : 43.42% (33/76) [00:34] remains: ec2 and arm [00:35] thanks jibel, so tobin and carlos are both in north america, so fingers crossed remainder should get results added tonight. [00:35] I'll do the netbook tomorrow morning, and if we remove wubi from the list we are all set. Tomorrow we'll be able to test the few run once testcase. [00:35] * skaet otherwise tomorrow's going to get exciting. [00:36] * skaet nods [00:36] it would be better if carlos test ec2 rather than raid1. anyone can test raid1 unlike ec2 [00:37] hggdh, ^ what do you think ? can we have some results about ec2 ? [00:38] jamespage can do raid1 tomorrow morning (GMT) [00:38] jibel: please have a look at the ec2 results... they are being updated [00:38] jibel, I think hggdh is has some results ready from jenkins runs, just hasn't transcribed. [00:38] * skaet hopes so, at any rate [00:39] heh [00:39] hggdh, oh great, I'll hit the refresh button faster next time. many thanks! [00:40] skaet: indeed, we have to look at each one, we are still building up the ec2 tests on jenkins (results are spread around) [00:41] GrueMaster, ^^ will you be able to get through most of the arm cases tonight? [00:41] I'm still turning and burning. [00:41] I have the kubuntu-mobile left. I've pinged the kubuntu team about the remaining omap3 image. I can test it as a last resort though. [00:42] * skaet thinks that "turning and burning" should be a song lyric. ... [00:43] GrueMaster, if we don't get omap3 coverage from kubuntu team, and you don't have bandwidth to get to it, we'll just hold the image until it is tested. Won't be a blocker on announce. [00:44] good night everyone ! [00:45] thanks jibel! sleep well. [01:09] skaet: done [01:09] skaet: meaning EC2 [01:09] * hggdh needs a wisky [01:12] A? No specific quantity? [01:15] I could use one too [01:15] hggdh, single malt or blend? [01:15] make it big! [01:15] * skaet can use one as well. [01:15] hggdh, thanks! [01:16] skaet: heh. Right now alcohol content is more important ;-) But single malt whenever possible [01:16] charlie-tca: I am with you! [01:16] :D +1 [01:19] is kubuntu mobile the only non-arm iso left to test? [01:20] nevermind, I'm being dumb [01:20] cyphermox, I believe so, but additional coverage on the desktop images after the respin would be very welcome from a double check/sanity perspective. [01:23] certainly, if this can wait until tomorrow (because I'm about to leave this café, it's about to close and need to sleep eventually) [01:23] tomorrow I'll have access to more cpu cycles too, starting 7am est [01:23] skaet, that kubuntu mobile image doesn't seem to have a correct page for the iso with md5sums and all [01:24] cyphermox, understand. rest up. we may be respinning some desktops tomorrow. [01:24] cyphermox, hmm... ok will look into the kubuntu mobile image and see if I can figure out what happened. [01:25] ok, further respins for desktop? [01:26] cyphermox, the WUBI/grub memory allocation bug is causing some discussions. [01:26] ah [01:26] not sure about outcome yet. [01:27] what time would the respins be done by? [01:27] I wonder if I could schedule rsync early for all the isos to be retrieved by the time I get to work [01:27] dependent on how long it takes colin to do the fix. [01:28] skaet, duh, right [01:28] fingers crossed if we go that route, start of the morning. [01:30] heh. even the casper bugs open against Live for Desktop amd64/i386 look nasty but hardware-specific [01:31] I'll be happy to do some cross-checking with some hardware I have early tomorrow :) [02:17] skaet: well, currently single-stepping through lots of grub code ... [02:17] I can't stay up much longer though [02:18] cjwatson, I'm sorry - no easy fix then? [02:20] I'm sure it'll turn out to be easy when I figure out where it goes [02:20] but I have only tenuous threads of a clue so far [02:29] [5~/wg 29 [02:29] sigh [03:13] jibel: what's the best way to report translation bugs (as in text that needs to be translated)? [03:14] jibel_ ^ [04:17] skaet: the debugging environment is very painful, but I *think* the line where it's going wrong is shortly after 'set root=(loop0)'. That's been a problem in the past (GRUB lost hold of the old root device when changing root to the loopback device), but I patched that, the patch went upstream, and I've checked that it's still there. Still, this looks like a promising line of attack. [04:18] cjwatson, glad a possible root cause has been uncovered. :) [04:18] * skaet thinks very painful, was an understatement. [04:19] skaet: it seems fine when running commands by hand, so I think it has to be something to do with reading data from a file while the root device is changed [04:20] I'm still guessing a bit [04:20] race condition? [04:20] no [04:20] good [04:20] it's all synchronous [04:20] GRUB is single-threaded [04:20] deterministic is good. :) [04:21] near enough deterministic anyway. It sometimes fails in slightly different ways, or manages to pass briefly depending on memory layout. [04:22] very painful was an understatent. [04:23] all very odd though. the device is meant to be resolved at open time and held until the grub_file_t is freed. [04:23] so I can't claim to quite know what's going on yet. [04:24] Am sort of wondering if some sort of stomp is going on (field over run, that changes state).. [04:24] can't say as yet [04:24] yeah [04:25] glad you've found a line of attack. Calling it a night? [04:25] yeah, probably [04:25] Anything you need me to keep an eye on if so? [04:26] nothing in particular, just test state and such in case any new showstoppers arise [04:26] * skaet has a couple more hours edit in the bugs to the release notes, etc. [04:26] I don't think wubi's going to make the cut this time, TBH [04:26] which is deeply irritating [04:27] * skaet nods [04:27] I'm composing my text to warn folks away from it now. Will let others massage it tomorrow. [04:28] I'm seeng a lot of crashes in kubuntu desktop on armel (both omap & omap4). Not sure what is critical and what isn't. I have a functional desktop so I don't think there are any show stoppers. [04:29] One issue I have is that they have their own crash handler that reports to bugs.kde.org. So I have to file it there, then file it here and link the two before adding it to the iso tracker. [04:29] it could be nothing to do with my hypothesis above and actually be a buffer overflow in grub_file_getline or something; we'll see. All I've actually proven is that it's somewhere in read_config_file [04:30] GrueMaster, ok. Will look forward to adding lots of bug/warnings then in the notes tomorrow from that area. Thanks for the head's up. [04:31] cjwatson, fresh eyes in the morning, will hopefully make it clear. [04:31] I'm only doing a basic boot/login test. I'll let the kubuntu folks do the app testing. This is painfully slow without video acceleration. [04:31] And SD makes it even slower. [04:32] GrueMaster, urk, sounds like you've been having a painfull evening as well. yuch. [04:34] * skaet has been translating bug titles into prose for a hundred or so bugs... [04:34] Need a script for that. :P [04:35] Used the script to get them into a form, I could start to work with them. [04:35] Not sure how to get folk to write better bug titles though... which is what it will take to truly automate it. [04:35] Sounds like the script needs work to do bug presentation right...file a bug on it. [04:36] lol [04:37] GrueMaster, can you print out the kernel version for me on the OMAP4 images? [04:38] linux-image-2.6.38-1207-omap4 2.6.38-1207.10 from the manifest. [04:39] Grrr. The KDE crash handler took so long to come up, I forgot what crashed and it doesn't say when asking for a bug title. [04:39] thanks! [04:55] The pain! 55 minutes to file a bug. === skaet is now known as skaet_zzz [09:20] hi all, [09:20] any non-english testers volunteers for the remaining i386 cases: http://iso.qa.ubuntu.com/qatracker/test/5335 ? [09:30] jibel hey [09:33] Good morning rickspencer3 [09:33] hey jibel I hear there are some wubi issues with beta 1, other than that, how do you feel about the release? [09:41] rickspencer3, the major issues are wubi, powerpc images doesn't boot, iscsi on server, and sound/video issues on arm. Ubiquity and upgrade issues have been fixed. Apart from that, it looks good. [09:42] we still have power pc images? [09:42] rickspencer3, yes, someone signed-up to test them. [09:44] interesting [09:48] jibel do you have a bug # on the iscsi on server issue [09:49] rickspencer3, bug 728088 [09:49] Launchpad bug 728088 in debian-installer (Ubuntu Natty) (and 1 other project) "iscsi root (amd64) with or without auth fails to boot (affects: 1) (heat: 132)" [High,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/728088 [09:54] jibel what is the impact of that bug? [09:55] server can't read scsi drives? [09:55] correct [09:55] not scsi, iScsi [09:55] iscsi are network storage devices [10:01] I see [10:02] that's unfortunate, but doesn't seem totally critical [10:02] I mean, for beta 1 [10:02] jibel are there bug #s for the ARM issues? [10:06] rickspencer3, bug 746133 , bug 651302 [10:06] Launchpad bug 746133 in linux-ti-omap4 (Ubuntu) "Video loses sync on omap4 (affects: 1) (heat: 6)" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/746133 [10:06] Launchpad bug 651302 in alsa-lib (Ubuntu Natty) (and 3 other projects) "No sound in omap (beagle, beagleXM). (affects: 4) (heat: 28)" [Low,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/651302 [10:07] oh my [10:07] those indeed should not block beta1 [10:07] sure [10:08] there are no release critical bugs. [10:36] Riddell, ping [10:37] hi jibel [10:38] Riddell, hi, do I need a specific setup to test kubuntu mobile ? [10:38] jibel: no but I've just tested it and it doesn't work so don't worry about it [10:39] at least we have the right bits on the image now so we have made progress :) [10:40] Riddell, oh fine. All I get is a black screen and I found no errors in the logs. So I was wondering I did something wrong [10:40] Riddell, do you have a bug number to update the tracker ? [10:40] jibel: yes the nodm login manager doesn't seem to be happy, I'm using bug 712061 [10:40] Launchpad bug 712061 in kubuntu-mobile-default-settings (Ubuntu Natty) (and 1 other project) "kubuntu mobile images fail to load (affects: 1) (heat: 70)" [Medium,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/712061 [10:40] Riddell, thanks [10:41] * Image Coverage : 100.00% (76/76) \o/ [10:42] awooga [10:47] Riddell, http://iso.qa.ubuntu.com/qatracker/result/5332/859 is the same on arm ? [10:47] jibel: yes that'll be the same issue [11:39] jibel, ping [12:58] patrickmw, pong, already up ? [13:00] jibel: good morning [13:00] patrickmw: good morning also :-) [13:00] good morning hggdh [13:00] thanks for ec2 testing [13:04] hggdh, shall we mark http://iso.qa.ubuntu.com/qatracker/result/5241/286 as done or failed ? fisx for bug 728435 is confirmed ? [13:04] Launchpad bug 728435 in mdadm (Ubuntu Natty) (and 1 other project) "raid1 boot degraded mode fails (affects: 2) (heat: 141)" [High,Fix released] https://launchpad.net/bugs/728435 [13:05] s/fisx/fix [13:05] looking [13:07] jibel, it is done, and the bug seems fixed [13:11] hggdh, ok, thanks. Only one mandatory testcase left then: Install (manual partitioning) on Ubuntu Desktop amd64+mac [13:14] anybody else was seeing long delays in the "Erase and install" screen in ubiquity in a VM? [13:15] cyphermox, what do you mean by 'long delays' ? [13:15] I clicked "Next"two or three minutes ago, it's still "processing" I guess [13:15] patrickmw, what's the status of http://iso.qa.ubuntu.com/qatracker/result/5333/448 ? [13:16] cyphermox, with vbox and dynamic sizing of the storage device that's much faster. [13:16] running in kvm [13:17] cyphermox, even in kvm with a 4GB drive [13:17] jibel, fwiw, I'm running the same test as patrickmw but on i386... [13:17] cyphermox, any trace of error is syslog ? [13:18] jibel, ah, so there is! [13:18] thx [13:20] anyone for our beloved 'migration assistant' test case ? [13:24] jibel, thanks, filed bug 746408 [13:24] Launchpad bug 746408 in ubiquity (Ubuntu) ""Erase entire disk..." crashes in CJK install with Korean language (affects: 1) (heat: 6)" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/746408 [13:29] patrickmw, ^ did you see the same error ? [13:30] cyphermox, thanks [13:34] Is the beta image available yet? === war10ck is now known as pan1nx [13:59] jibel: just tried live and the issue for my wifi is still in place, I'll mark it on the tracker asap (first chance I've had) [14:08] jibel: still the bug with the 4px ubiquity panel too [14:09] jibel, i'm doing migration assistant [14:44] Good morning [14:44] no respins today, right? [14:52] jibel, why was the iso testing tag added to: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/open-vm-tools/+bug/727342 [14:52] Launchpad bug 727342 in open-vm-tools (Ubuntu) "FFE: open-vm-tools kernel module failed to build (affects: 29) (dups: 36) (heat: 390)" [Critical,New] [14:57] pgraner, a bug has been reported on the tracker then marked as dup of this one. There is a job that processes all the bugs added to the tracker and tag them iso-testing. [14:58] jibel, ok, thx made no sense at the time, it does now. Thanks. [14:59] pgraner, yw [15:02] cjwatson, bug 739774 looks like an ancient ghost. what's the way to disable floppy scanning from the kernel command line ? [15:02] Launchpad bug 739774 in casper (Ubuntu) "live session from usb key take very long to start (40 min.) (affects: 2) (heat: 398)" [Undecided,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/739774 [15:04] davmor2, do you have the bug number for the 4px panel, I cant find it [15:04] jibel: I do one second I'll add both [15:06] https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/ubuntu/natty/+source/ubiquity/+bug/727726 [15:06] Launchpad bug 727726 in ubiquity (Ubuntu Natty) (and 1 other project) "ubiquity panel is about 4px instead of 30 on install (affects: 2) (heat: 140)" [Low,Confirmed] [15:10] davmor2, thanks [15:11] jibel: I'll add it to the tracker asap with another couple === skaet_zzz is now known as skaet [15:21] charlie-tca, no respin today. you look disappointed ? [15:21] jibel: I don't know offhand, brain isn't really working today [15:22] cjwatson, np [15:25] jibel: of course. no respin leaves at least half a day empty :-) [15:26] charlie-tca, you can always help with triaging bugs tagged iso-testing :-) [15:27] I can do that! [15:27] * charlie-tca never thought of seaching on that tag === yofel_ is now known as yofel [16:08] hiya jibel, by my scan, the only gaps in the mandatory tests at this point are on the powerpc images. Can you confirm? [16:10] skaet, hi, [16:11] :) [16:11] skaet, Install (manual partitioning) on Ubuntu Desktop amd64+mac is the only mandatory testcase left [16:12] skaet, powerpc doesn't boot, so all the testcases have been set to failed. [16:13] jibel thanks [16:13] skaet, remaining run once: on ubuntu-desktop i386, screen reader install, cjk install and migration assistant [16:13] any other things to double check are marked in the release notes? (PowerPC not booting is there) [16:13] heh :) [16:13] on ubuntu-dekstop amd64 screen-reader installation [16:14] jibel, migration assistant is done [16:14] just completed it [16:14] pedro_, right, well that's the other way around but you have the big pictures i386 <->amd64 [16:16] jibel, I did not get that error with amd64 [16:16] patrickmw, can you update the status to pass or fail please. [16:17] jibel: yes :) but I need assistance on documented the bug [16:17] s/documented/documenting [16:18] urgh, brb, I need to logout/in, unity is entering the 4rth dimension [16:28] phew, that's was longer than expected. [16:28] patrickmw, howcan I help ? [16:28] jibel, bug 746500 [16:28] Launchpad bug 746500 in ubuntu-translations (and 2 other projects) "ubiquity cjk translations are not complete for natty installer and slideshow (affects: 1) (heat: 6)" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/746500 [16:30] jibel I was also unable to reproduce bug 746408 on i386 or amd64 [16:30] Launchpad bug 746408 in ubiquity (Ubuntu Natty) (and 1 other project) ""Erase entire disk..." crashes in CJK install with Korean language (affects: 1) (heat: 6)" [High,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/746408 [16:55] patrickmw, sorry, was otp [16:56] about 746408, I don't knwn it seems that the label of the disk is in korean [16:57] and ubiquity doesn't like it [16:59] skaet, I reviewed the release notes and reports tagged iso-testing. The major issues are there, the other bugs found in lp are unconfirmed [17:01] jibel, thank you!! [19:41] I clicked beta link in this page - http://www.ubuntu.com/testing [19:41] and it says page not found [19:42] 11.04 beta1 released today ? [19:42] nagappan, yes. there are problems with the link. let me get you one that works [19:42] patrickmw, sure, thanks :-) [19:43] nagappan: http://ubuntu-releases.eecs.wsu.edu/natty/ [19:43] patrickmw, I asked the question to jibel in #ldtp about my bug https://bugs.launchpad.net/unity/+bug/742880 any suggestion for me ? [19:43] Launchpad bug 742880 in unity (Ubuntu) (and 1 other project) "Unity doesn't work on ATI ES1000 card (affects: 1) (heat: 10)" [Undecided,Incomplete] [19:43] patrickmw, thanks, let me check [19:44] nagappan, did you still the proprietary drivers? [19:46] nagappan, I see lamalex made a comment on your bug. He would be a could person to contact [19:47] nagappan, you can find him in #ubuntu-desktop [19:51] patrickmw, okay [19:51] patrickmw, how do I check I'm using proprietary driver ? [19:52] nagappan , jockey-text -l [19:54] nagappan, for an ati card you should see something like this [19:54] xorg:fglrx - ATI/AMD proprietary FGLRX graphics driver (Proprietary, Enabled, In use) === McPeter_ is now known as McPeter [20:31] nagappan, hi, you were using radeon which is thre opensource driver. lamalex could have opened the log file [20:52] jibel, okay, thanks [20:53] patrickmw, I don't see any message for "jockey-text -l" [20:54] patrickmw, I have installed fglrx and rebooted the system as well [20:58] nagappan, fglrx can't be installed with jockey yet and requires unity from a ppa https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-x/2011-March/001065.html [21:06] jibel: added those two bugs to the tracker there is an ati/amd install issue too but I can't look into it till tomorrow. [22:43] jibel, okay [23:03] Hi all, well its official. 11.04 announce has been sent! [23:03] A Big Thank You to hggdh, jibel, chadadavis, pedro_, charlie-tca, njin, jamespage, ptn107, smoser, highvoltage, PatrickDK, Knightlust, ScottK, xdatap1, PaoloRotolo, starslights, pitti, superm1, stanz, Letozaf_, jledbetter, Fly82, guillemhs, primes2h, zul, valix, Daviey, totopalma, homitsu, francescobrozzu, freefly, cariboo907, davmor2, gjditchfield and cyphermox for testing the ISOs [23:04] skaet: you are welcome, and thanks to you for all your efforts on this! === meganerdca is now known as mbineganerdca [23:05] skaet, My pleasure :) Was fun! thanks to the team for making it so easy for a new person to do it! [23:06] Thanks you all for testing and to skaet for managing the milestone release ! [23:07] :) glad it was fun for you, jledbetter, hope you'll join us next time. [23:07] jibel, thanks for pulling it all together and keeping us coordinated! [23:16] thanks to all :-) === mbineganerdca is now known as meganerdca