[15:00] * vorlon waves [15:00] * cyphermox waves [15:00] o/ [15:00] o/ [15:01] o/ [15:01] \o [15:02] #startmeeting [15:02] Meeting started Thu Mar 14 15:02:22 2019 UTC. The chair is vorlon. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.ubuntu.com/meetingology. [15:02] Available commands: action commands idea info link nick [15:02] o/ [15:02] [TOPIC] Lightning round === meetingology changed the topic of #ubuntu-meeting to: Lightning round [15:02] $ echo $(shuf -e vorlon bdmurray xnox tdaitx doko sil2100 rbalint infinity cyphermox mwhudson juliank waveform) [15:02] juliank cyphermox bdmurray xnox waveform mwhudson tdaitx infinity sil2100 rbalint vorlon doko [15:02] one sec [15:02] Let's do the daily version: [15:03] Fri: [15:03] * apt: [15:03] * 1.8.0 release [15:03] * cherry-picking of the new fixes from 1.8.0 to stable branches [15:03] * merging translations down the branches (1.8->1.7->1.6->1.2->trusty) [15:03] - probably should do 1.6->1.4 then 1.4->1.2, though. [15:03] Mon: [15:03] * apt 1.7.4 and 1.6.30 stable release updates [15:03] * python-apt 1.8.4 release, fixing a few locking bugs [15:03] Tue: [15:03] * apt 1.2.31 and 1.0.1ubuntu2.22 stable release updates [15:03] Wed: [15:03] * Updated socket-activated debconf client helper for PackageKit (https://github.com/hughsie/PackageKit/pull/289) [15:03] * some trello card splitting [15:03] Thu: [15:03] * Investigated ubuntu-drivers for aptdaemon usage -> only in tests [15:03] * Merged minimize-manual for live-cdrootfs/bionic [15:03] * Discussed private ppa support for add-apt-repository with ddstreet and cjwatson (bug 645404) [15:03] bug 645404 in software-properties (Ubuntu) "Support Private PPAs" [Low,Triaged] https://launchpad.net/bugs/645404 [15:03] * More work on ESM UX [15:03] (done) [15:03] grub2 uploaded for adding the http module to EFI binary + plymouth fixes [15:04] preparing grub2 SRUs for http module, debconf prompts [15:04] cleaning up / revising the packageset update script for the DMB [15:04] debugging netplan.io autopkgtests: wifi tests failing on some architectures (on purpose), etc. [15:04] prepared and uploaded netplan.io SRUs for bionic, cosmic (now in queue) [15:04] (done) [15:04] research into how to use prometheus client for the Error Tracker [15:04] discussed with IS using a script to convert json instead [15:04] worked on conversion of an ET cronjob from pycassa to python cassandra [15:04] searched for a gdb patch for bug LP: #1818918 [15:04] Launchpad bug 1818918 in gdb (Ubuntu) "gdb doesn't search in debug-file-directory for .gnu_debugaltlink" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1818918 [15:04] reported ET bug re long LP bug titles (LP: #1819199) [15:04] reported apport bug re gdbsandbox and libc6 (LP: #1819230) [15:04] review and merge of azzar1's fix for LP: #1816423 [15:04] worked on lintian issues with ubuntu-release-upgrader [15:04] reuploaded distro-info for C and T with proper deps [15:04] Launchpad bug 1819199 in Errors "bug creator can create very long bug titles" [Low,Triaged] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1819199 [15:04] Launchpad bug 1819230 in Apport "gdb sandbox creation should use report's libc6 version" [Medium,Triaged] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1819230 [15:04] Launchpad bug 1816423 in ubuntu-release-upgrader (Ubuntu) "Tells you that livepatch will be disabled when it wasn't enabled before" [Medium,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1816423 [15:04] done [15:04] xnox: [15:04] * Fix up LP: #1805841 [15:04] * Completed LP: #1766865 for LUKS2/partman-crypto [15:04] * Fixing up MAAS images for LUKS2 LP: #1818876 [15:04] * Upstreaming s390-tools fixes for zkey LUKS2 [15:04] Launchpad bug 1805841 in Ubuntu on IBM z Systems "CPI information about kvm usage is lost during apt upgrade" [Medium,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1805841 [15:04] * Worked on [15:04] https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/atlas/+bug/1814796 to get [15:04] Launchpad bug 1766865 in Ubuntu on IBM z Systems "[19.04 FEAT] Installer support for protected key dm-crypt" [High,Triaged] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1766865 [15:04] to incomplete state, the provided patches FTBFS [15:04] Launchpad bug 1818876 in maas-images "maas images lack enough of crypto for cryptsetup in the ephemeral images" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1818876 [15:04] * Worked on [15:05] Launchpad bug 1814796 in Ubuntu on IBM z Systems "[19.04 FEAT] Provide optimized libatlas libraries for different types of z Systems" [Medium,Incomplete] [15:05] https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/lvm2/+bug/1817097 to [15:05] Launchpad bug 1817097 in lvm2 "pvmove causes file system corruption without notice upon move from 512 -> 4096 logical block size devices" [Medium,Confirmed] [15:05] incomplete state, actually not critical, well-known, provided [15:05] workaround [15:05] * There are no outstanding foundations actionable items requested by [15:05] IBM for s390x for disco [15:05] = Blocked = [15:05] * Responded to the OpenSSL SRU questions, awaiting for openssl to be accepted [15:05] https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/openssl/+bug/1797386 [15:05] Launchpad bug 1797386 in openssl (Ubuntu) "[SRU] OpenSSL 1.1.1 to 18.04 LTS" [Undecided,In progress] [15:05] * Parter upload in unapproved [15:05] https://launchpad.net/ubuntu/xenial/+queue?queue_state=1&queue_text=ibm-java80 [15:05] https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ibm-java71/+bug/1818799 [15:05] Launchpad bug 1818799 in Ubuntu on IBM z Systems "[Comm] IBM JDK 8.0.5.30 integration into Ubuntu" [High,In progress] [15:05] = Bugs to review = [15:05] * multipath bug (out of my breadth, maybe cpa) [15:05] https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/multipath-tools/+bug/1815599 [15:05] Launchpad bug 1815599 in multipath-tools (Ubuntu) "multipath shows '#:#:#:#' for iscsi device after error injection" [Undecided,New] [15:05] * cryptsetup decrease memory requirement from 1GB to something tolarable [15:05] https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/cryptsetup/+bug/1820049 [15:05] Launchpad bug 1820049 in cryptsetup (Ubuntu) "cryptsetup 2.1.0 requires excessive amount of RAM ( 1GB ) to luksOpen encrypted drives" [Undecided,New] [15:05] done [15:06] * sil2100 pokes waveform [15:07] * Finished pi "amazing" spec; in for review [15:07] * Moving RPi patches from livecd-rootfs to linux-firmware-raspi2 (needs review) [15:07] * SRU for RPi.GPIO to bionic / cosmic [15:07] * Upgraded wiringPi package to 2.50 version [15:07] waveform, it's Pi day! [15:07] * Testing of pi-bluetooth package on Pi3B, 3B+, (need to do 3A+) under arm64 (need to verify armhf) [15:07] * Investigating integration of pi-bluetooth fixes into ubuntu core [15:07] * More reading on ARM trustzone [15:07] (done) [15:07] * openjdk-11 bionic security transition [15:07] - reviewed & uploaded packages [15:07] - bumped & rebuild arch specific packages for cosmic [15:07] - prepared openjdk-11 upload for cosmic [15:07] * ant fix for mrjar LP: #1808383 [15:07] * unable to reproduce sweethome3d menu bug (chroot & qemu) LP: #1816791 [15:07] Launchpad bug 1808383 in ant (Ubuntu Disco) "Java 9+ multi-release jars are not supported in ant tasks" [Medium,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1808383 [15:07] (done) [15:07] Launchpad bug 1816791 in sweethome3d (Ubuntu) "18.04 backport doesn't properly display menu entries" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1816791 [15:07] - Friday: out-of-office [15:07] - A very long and busy DMB meeting [15:07] - SRU reviews and releases [15:07] - New kernel cycle starting [15:07] - Help with package copies for OpenJDK-11 bionic/cosmic [15:07] - Reviewing Steve's ubuntu-cdimage clean-up branch (first step) [15:08] - core18 [15:08] * Started cleanup in gadget branch permissions (again) [15:08] * Released new core18 [15:08] * Prepared updates for gadgets [15:08] - Packaging the WALA security fix and testing the packages + coordination [15:08] - Booking for the release sprint [15:08] - Addressing Laney's review concerns in the ADT-regression bug notifier [15:08] (done) [15:08] * added detecting wsl to systemd-detect-virt https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/11932 [15:08] * fixed libcec ftbfs with 4.0.4+dfsg1-2 via Debian [15:08] * uploaded wireshark 3.0.0 to experimental (in NEW now) [15:08] * tested reboot speed cycles on an old laptop [15:08] - suggested using dbus for reboot since sudo reboot bypasses inhibitor locks [15:08] * verified many SRU-d unattended-upgrades bugs for Xenial [15:08] * partner work [15:08] (done) [15:09] vorlon: [15:09] * reverting resolvconf SRU due to regressions (LP: #1819625) [15:09] * TB work [15:09] * more trusty ESM transition discussions [15:09] * plotting around secureboot policy transition and FIPS kernels [15:09] * looking at a possible regression in trusty that may be the kernel refusing to load kernel modules signed with a key it doesn't know, while loading completely unsigned kernels (LP: #1818134) [15:09] Launchpad bug 1819625 in resolvconf (Ubuntu) "Package resolvconf=1.79ubuntu10.18.04.1 broken" [Undecided,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1819625 [15:09] Launchpad bug 1818134 in bcmwl (Ubuntu) "modprobe: ERROR: could not insert 'wl': Package not installed ubuntu14.04.5LTS kernel 3.13.0-165-generic" [Undecided,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1818134 [15:09] * debian-cd, cdimage MPs for the desktop team (multilayer squashfs and canary image) [15:10] (done) [15:10] doko: [15:13] vorlon: so no doko? [15:13] guess not [15:13] any questions over status? [15:14] * juliank has gone sightly mad [15:15] xnox: on openssl, did you put your response in the SRU bug template? [15:16] vorlon: none here [15:16] ohh, US summer time? [15:16] doko: yeah [15:17] sorry, didn't prepare. but still doing openjdk-11 backports [15:17] ok [15:17] #topic Bugs === meetingology changed the topic of #ubuntu-meeting to: Bugs [15:17] bug 1818953 was assigned to our team [15:17] bug 1818953 in perl (Ubuntu Disco) "mblen() failing in Perl / Perl core dumping core on UBUNTU 19.04 by executing perl script, multiple architectures" [Critical,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1818953 [15:17] [LINK] http://reqorts.qa.ubuntu.com/reports/rls-mgr/rls-dd-incoming-bug-tasks.html#foundations-bugs [15:17] there is a patch proposed by debina developer [15:17] * vorlon nods [15:17] if no traction there, will upload into ubuntu [15:18] xnox: so should you be the assignee? [15:18] sure [15:18] there is a trello card as well for it [15:19] I don't know if infinity took it, we discussed it this week [15:19] the card has his symbol [15:19] xnox: ^^ [15:19] bdmurray: other bugs? [15:20] bug 1819427 [15:20] bug 1819427 in ubiquity (Ubuntu) "Disco daily install doens't include the snaps" [High,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1819427 [15:20] i am sure both infinity and I would love to just sync it, out of debian [15:20] xnox: that's fine, but whoever does it, please close out the card so I don't have to look at it again ;) [15:20] bdmurray, i thought some desktopy people mentioned that they are working on it. [15:21] that snap/daily install has been actively looked at by Ken/Will with the snap team and has been handed to the snapd team for investigation now since it looks like a bug on their side [15:21] bdmurray, and strictly not a regression, rather never enabled. [15:21] seb128, oh, ok, thanks. [15:21] seb128: should there be another task then? [15:21] xnox, that bug is not about the manifest, it's about the target system missing the seeded snap [15:21] snaps [15:21] doko: what was never enabled? [15:22] indeed [15:22] interesting [15:22] and anyway it doesn't look like a ubiquity bug based on the discussion [15:22] bdmurray, probably, I was waiting for them to figure out the details to triage/Reassign as appropriate [15:22] vorlon, listing snaps in desktop.iso's manifest [15:22] xnox, that's bug #1819287 and didrocks is looking at it [15:22] bug 1819287 in livecd-rootfs (Ubuntu) "snaps missing from manifests of daily desktop images" [High,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1819287 [15:23] other than ogra's comment its not clear its been handed off [15:23] it's being worked through the forum currently [15:23] I don't believe it's for Foundations to drive [15:23] maybe assign the bug to chipaca [15:24] (+1 for that) [15:25] it should be targeted to disco for sure, but unless snap team identifies something in livecd-rootfs, it's not-for-us [15:25] vorlon, sounds like we should raise it to the snapd team [15:25] it's being discussed atm on #snappy, I don't believe there is action needed on those issues [15:26] Okay should we move on then? [15:26] yes please [15:26] Does bug 1396160 seem worth fixing for disco? [15:26] bug 1396160 in apport (Ubuntu) "/usr/share/apport/recoverable_problem:PermissionError:/usr/share/apport/recoverable_problem@75:main:add_proc_info" [Medium,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1396160 [15:26] https://errors.ubuntu.com/problem/72c621876cfe04b51b37f8f3ef08c3da0460b462 is the most recent errors bucket [15:28] bdmurray: are you proposing it because it's currently the spammiest crash for us? [15:28] if so then +1 [15:28] Well, that and its a bad user experience getting the crash dialog for no reason. It came up because I hit it too. [15:29] Last one, bug 1816812. What is this even about? It doesn't seem very helpful. [15:29] bug 1816812 in systemd (Ubuntu Disco) "pull seb patch" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1816812 [15:30] bdmurray: right, but we know how many users the spurious dialog is affecting by how many reports we get :) [15:30] all gnome-classic and unity users have their logout not working [15:30] or rather timeouting and taking ages [15:31] sigh [15:31] https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/11697 has the details [15:31] ack [15:31] and it's a pretty simple patch [15:31] please just backport it :) [15:31] i think the solution is to merge the bugfix release v241 into disco [15:31] what could go wrong [15:31] cause our disco systemd is now v240,71 [15:31] given the number of patches we have [15:32] xnox: I don't think we need to micromanage the resolution :) do you agree that we need to get this bug fixed for disco? [15:32] yeah [15:32] ok. it's targeted, and I'll create a card for it that you can mangle to taste after [15:33] can I ask a rls-bug question/raise a point before you guys move to another topic? or is this meeting not the right venue? (I'm happy to email or go the appropriate way) [15:33] seb128: go ahead [15:33] my understand of the process was that rls--incoming list should be regularly reviewed and driven to 0 by acception or -notfixing things [15:34] but the foundations list has items sitting in place for months [15:34] so I'm unsure if it means we should escalade problems by some other mean? [15:34] e.g bug #1817453 is concerning desktop for the incoming release [15:34] bug 1817453 in ubiquity (Ubuntu) "19.04 installer displays keyboard layouts in the wrong language" [High,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1817453 [15:34] but doesn't seem to get reviewed [15:34] * xnox doesn't desktop own ubiquity?! [15:35] * seb128 slaps xnox [15:35] /kick xnox [15:35] ;) [15:35] bdmurray: have you triaged this bug in some other manner? [15:35] that's recent-ish [15:35] bug things like bug #1802337 are on the list since novembre [15:35] bug 1802337 in ubiquity (Ubuntu) "Please apply security updates during Ubuntu install" [Wishlist,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1802337 [15:35] vorlon: no [15:37] seb128: I think in general the volume is such that we don't get through the ones of medium or lower importance [15:37] k, good to know [15:37] but of course one of these you point out is high [15:37] right [15:37] bdmurray: should we take LP: #1817453 now? [15:37] Launchpad bug 1817453 in ubiquity (Ubuntu) "19.04 installer displays keyboard layouts in the wrong language" [High,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1817453 [15:37] seb128: keyboard layouts one is a regression, I'm reasonably sure [15:38] vorlon: I think so [15:38] vorlon, well, looking at the report you have 1 critical and 6 high on the list [15:38] heh, well, as per the bug obviously [15:38] seb128: some of those are tagged and targetted so on both lists [15:38] the process is to tag -notfixing or target/untag though [15:39] items should never stay on -incoming if you respect that [15:39] (we drive our list for desktop to 0 every week and it works) [15:40] the keyboard stuff sounds like an off-by-1 or something bug [15:40] bdmurray: so do we agree to drive this to 0 in the future, for crit+high? [15:40] vorlon, anyway, I didn't want to derail your meeting too long, I think it would have value to have the list driven to 0, but I also note that usually it would happen for items > medium [15:41] vorlon: sure [15:41] ok [15:41] thx! [15:41] seb128: thanks for raising [15:41] [TOPIC] proposed-migration === meetingology changed the topic of #ubuntu-meeting to: proposed-migration [15:41] np, thx for listening :) [15:41] [LINK] http://people.canonical.com/~ubuntu-archive/proposed-migration/disco/update_excuses_by_team.html#foundations-bugs [15:41] this is looking busier again [15:41] cyphermox: you have netplan.io in progress, right? [15:41] yes [15:42] xnox: you took fuse-zip last week; any progress? [15:42] finally figured a way to fix at least wifis [15:42] vorlon, no progress, no [15:42] cyphermox, vorlon can we add that to the wiki page for running the meeting - regarding driving crit+high on incoming to zero [15:43] cyphermox, vorlon and can we start using that wiki page to run the meetings? [15:43] if the wiki page is linked from an entry point ;) [15:44] um, rbalint, there are a lot of "apt_pkg.pkgsystem_unlock() failed due to not holding the lock but trying to continue" in the u-u test log [15:44] xnox: are you going to work on it this week? [15:44] yes [15:44] ok [15:44] doko: you had claimed epsilon, I think? [15:44]  [15:44] juliank, yes, this is a workaround for the lock being lost [15:45] (python-scipy is no longer blocking things except for python-numpy, hurray for regressions in release) [15:45] rbalint: but i thought we fixed it so we don't lose it anymore [15:45] vorlon, yes, we'll make that so #1 [15:45] vorlon: yes, still on my list, didn't find the time yet [15:45] ok [15:45] juliank, i hoped, but then python-apt/apt still looses it [15:45] juliank, it seems [15:45] juliank, it think it became better [15:46] e2fsprogs is blocked by initramfs-tools, which is a false-positive, just needs rerun now that mwhudson and I have fixed busybox vs isc-dhcp client (have clicked the button now) [15:46] but also blocked by systemd/arm64 [15:46] xnox: ^^ ? [15:46] juliank, is it in disco? [15:46] yeah [15:46] vorlon, lovely [15:46] xnox: not lovely, racy [15:46] vorlon, i had analysis pinged to me about arm64 from Laney, need to upload that. [15:46] I've clicked that button now too [15:46] ok [15:47] juliank, at least if you see that now often it became more reproducible :-) [15:47] python-numpy + python-scipy, I don't know if we have a path forward on resolving that [15:47] rbalint: it's in the most recent autopkgtest logs where I see it [15:47] we've badtest'ed python-scipy in release, so maybe we should just do the same for the proposed version [15:48] 657 messages like that in the latest [15:48] * Laney fluffles xnox [15:49] fwiw Debian isn't shipping the new scipy or the new numpy yet [15:49] rbalint: this should not happen at all, it should be calling apt_pkg.pkgsystem_unlock_inner [15:49] and lintian is the same issue as last time [15:50] so I think that covers the p-m stuff that currently needs attention [15:50] so, somehow, u-u ends up getting an AttributeError on apt_pkg.pkgsystem_unlock_inner() [15:50] juliank, it used to work [15:50] and juliank and rbalint are getting ahead on u-u + python-apt before the report marks it as 'late', +1 [15:50] [TOPIC] AOB === meetingology changed the topic of #ubuntu-meeting to: AOB [15:50] anything else? [15:51] (sorry for the noise, dodgy connection) [15:52] ah, no, it's upgrading debian testing, that's not going to help :) [15:52] um, stable [15:52] debian stable never got any of the frontend locking stuff or the locking fixes [15:53] juliank, it is upgrading snapshots, i'll move to newer snapshot points [15:54] well, that won't help, as there are no fixes in later snapshots either :) [15:54] juliank, no fix in sid? [15:54] Well, yes, in sid [15:54] but that looks like a install security updates in stable test? [15:54] maybe I'm wrong [15:54] which log are you looking at? [15:55] the latest [15:55] you two can have the side conversation post-meeting ;) [15:55] #endmeeting === meetingology changed the topic of #ubuntu-meeting to: Ubuntu Meeting Grounds: Please leave swords by the door | Calendar/Scheduled meetings: http://fridge.ubuntu.com/calendars | Logs: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/MeetingLogs | Meetingology documentation: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/meetingology | be nice [15:55] Meeting ended Thu Mar 14 15:55:10 2019 UTC. [15:55] Minutes: http://ubottu.com/meetingology/logs/ubuntu-meeting/2019/ubuntu-meeting.2019-03-14-15.02.moin.txt [15:55] thanks, all [15:56] * juliank -> #ubuntu-devel [15:58] vorlon: thanks o/ [16:11] vorlon, updated the regression potential section of the openssl sru bug report.